Google must upgrade hosted apps to appeal to IT, analysts say

Computerworld - Google Inc. must provide stronger data models, along with role-based access and records management archiving capabilities, before most IT managers will take its Google Apps hosted application suite seriously, analysts said this week.

The search tool maker's hosted offerings are getting a closer look by IT managers looking to compare them with Microsoft's Online Services hosted offering, which was unveiled last September.

"I think Google has underestimated the complexity of the enterprise space," said Guy Creese, an analyst at Midvale, Utah-based Burton Group. "So far, they basically have [delivered] consumer products and slapped an enterprise name on them. They talk a lot about usability, but they fall down" because of the lack of an enterprise data model.

In an interview with Computerworld this week at the AIIM Conference in Boston, Matthew Glotzbach, director of product management for enterprise at Google, noted that 500,000 organizations are using Google Apps, though he also acknowledged that large organizations are hesitant so far to join in.

"One challenge we've had is building that enterprise credibility," conceded Glotzbach, who added that the company expects the consumer and business versions of Google Apps to maintain "90% consistency" going forward.

Creese said Google must further differentiate the versions, noting that several new features must be added to meet the needs of large IT operations. Some of those include data archiving tools to augment records management searches, e-mail distribution list functionalities and role-based management tools.

"Somebody worried about a soccer schedule is not worried about records management -- and they don't have a distribution list," Creese noted about the difference between consumer and business users. "It's all of this underlying way of managing the business that [Google] is missing."

Matt Cain, an analyst at Stamford, Conn.-based Gartner Inc., added that Google Apps likely won't be seriously considered by enterprises until the company can show it can support reporting, audit trails and service-level agreements of large-scale commercial users.

"[Google] has everything else, but that's what we need to see. They need to prove it," remarked Cain. "There's a lot of skepticism and let's wait and see," among corporate users.

Nonetheless, he expects Google and Microsoft to be the primary providers of hosted applications to corporate users when Gartner expects the market to take off between 2010 and 2012.

Google first launched the Google Apps offering in 2006 as a free service and began charging in 2007 with the introduction of a Premier Edition. Last week, Google further beefed up the service by adding the Google Sites wiki service to the service's Google Docs, Gmail, Google Calendar and Talk applications.

Microsoft this week countered the addition of Google Sites -- an obvious competitor of Microsoft SharePoint -- by unveiling beta versions of hosted Exchange and SharePoint server products. The hosted Microsoft offerings will be generally available by the end of 2008, the company said.

Cain said the software company will trail Google Apps' capabilities until it adds Microsoft Office applications to the hosted suite.

"If you look at the way the industry is playing out and the way Google is going, I would have to imagine that the lights are burning long and bright over in Redmond working on hosted versions of Office," Cain said.

Read more about saas in Computerworld's SaaS Knowledge Center.