A standard that leaves out the good stuff?
Vendors tend to offer the lowest common denominator of functionality
Computerworld - A specification meant to bring together storage device management under one umbrella instead continues to be criticized for its innate inability to enable interoperable functionality.
The Storage Management Initiative Specification (SMI-S) is a lightning rod for controversy among both its supporters and detractors. It has been approved by the ISO international standards organization and the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) as a standard for interoperable storage management technologies. Yet detractors say SMI-S was overhyped and will never fulfill its original promise of integrating storage device management across the industry. Supporters continue to say SMI-S is opening storage resource management (SRM) doors that were previously locked by proprietary vendors.
SMI-S, now in Version 1.02, grew out of the Storage Management Initiative (SMI), which was created by the Storage Networking Industry Association (SNIA) in 2002. SMI-S is criticized for not being more open to smaller SRM vendors and failing to help end user IT organizations establish centralized control over their heterogeneous storage infrastructures because larger vendors will not port the most sophisticated application programming interfaces (API) to the standard's framework.
That criticism is countered by SNIA and many large members of the vendor trade group who say that even though SMI-S implementations have lagged behind the rapidly evolving standard, both vendors and users are benefiting from it.
The basic concept behind SMI-S is simple: Vendors translate product specifications into XML code for their specific storage management software, which creates a universal API that can be accessed by any other SMI-S-compatible products. SNIA says that about 450 products from 30 vendors have so far passed the SNIA Conformance Testing Program for SMI-S. Product types include storage networking components (such as arrays, switches and host bus adapters) and their associated management software, as well as client software.
Slowing down the development process?
Marty LeFebvre, Nielsen Media Research's vice president of technology and a member of the SNIA End-User Council governing board, says the problem with SMI-S is broad and one of vendor reluctance for interoperability.
"There's a certain amount of feeling among end users that if we had a more direct conduit to [vendor] product managers, we might be able to make more progress toward that," he says. "But part of it also is [that] instead of each vendor trying to solve the whole thing front to back, if there was a little of collaboration to where individual vendors could solve a pieces of it and then there was interoperability between the software, just as we're talking about interoperability between hardware, that might help advance that."
LeFabvre said when end users talk about SRM, it encompasses a broad range of functionality, such as provisioning, capacity planning, automated response to performance issues and load balancing. "To try to solve that front to back is a tall order," he recognizes.
- ESG Lab Report: Virident FlashMAX Connect Performance Advantage with vCache on a single Oracle instance View Now>>
- Accelerating Oracle with Preferred Reads Storage based configuration. View Now>>
- What is this "File Sync" Thing and Why Should I Care About It? All of a sudden, getting a file from your work laptop to your iPad became as simple as clicking "Save." So it's no...
- The Keys to Securing Data in a Collaborative Workplace Losing data is costly. IT professionals have spent years learning how to protect their organizations from hackers, but how do you ward off...
- The Key to Happiness: Throw out Your Data Warehouse In this webinar, Kerry Reitnauer, Director, Solution Architect at FairPoint Communications will discuss the challenges the data warehouse brought, how they migrated to...
- The Foundation You Need to Build a Better Storage Infrastructure Watch this webcast to hear how you can maximize the economics of your data center by modifying your storage footprint and power usage... All Data Storage White Papers | Webcasts