YouTube fans rant, threaten to leave over new ads
Revolt in progress, or just usual change-related fussing?
IDG News Service - YouTube might need to rethink its new InVideo advertising scheme, based on initial feedback Wednesday to the popular video-sharing Web site.
The responses, a total of 132 as of this writing, may best be summarized by the first post: "Yuck," wrote user quepasakoolj18 of Oro Valley, Ariz.
The new InVideo ads, launched by Google Inc.'s YouTube division on Wednesday, start as an overlay on the bottom 20% of a video, and people can click and watch the advertisement if they want to. If the user does not click on the overlay, the ad will simply disappear. They are designed to interfere as little as possible with viewing. If a user clicks on the advertisement, the video they are watching pauses while the ad plays.
One responder to the YouTube blog post, bdc2005, was disappointed about an apparent lack of creativity in the advertising scheme. "You guys ripped off VideoEgg. What happened to innovation?" the posting said.
And a banner on VideoEgg Inc.'s home page says in bold letters, "Welcome YouTube, Seriously. We invented the video overlay ad about a year ago. We are delighted that the market is finally catching on to a vital new approach to video advertising."
YouTube could not be reached for comment. The company did not claim to invent the idea, merely that it would launch the overlays.
Changing channels and "art" attacks
Mostly, users expressed dissatisfaction over the new ad scheme, and a number said they would turn to other Web sites that host videos in response to the move.
"Please don't ruin the YouTube experience. I really don't want to have to upload all my videos to a different site. But I will," wrote drivin98.
Several users did not like the intrusion on creativity. "These videos are made by us, for us, and should not see the creative content impeded," wrote video maker EloiCasali.
Cenzo74 said the advertisements will taint the videos, and could contain content the video owner personally dislikes or is against.
"Video is art. Film is art. And for you to paint over their artwork is a complete atrocity. Place your ads somewhere else," he wrote.
Placing advertisements elsewhere or finding other ways to make money were another major theme of the responses. Mainyard48 prefers pre-roll ads, while other users asked for advertisements beside videos, or above or below them -- "but not in the video," wrote user Tupisuis. Several people even asked to be charged for a premium service that did not include advertising.
Some people came to YouTube's defense, with user Avum pointing out it is spending a lot of money to host all of the videos on its Web site and needs to make money to pay for that.
There were also signs that other users might come around to the idea. Some of the postings indicated that the user had not actually seen the new video overlays, but had merely heard about them. User glennrr wrote that it was "not as bad as it sounded. Good job."
To be sure, the idea is new and some people could get used to it over time. But the overall tenor of the responses was negative and indicate that most YouTube users would rather find another video-sharing Web site than be forced to watch advertisements.
- 15 Non-Certified IT Skills Growing in Demand
- How 19 Tech Titans Target Healthcare
- Twitter Suffering From Growing Pains (and Facebook Comparisons)
- Agile Comes to Data Integration
- Slideshow: 7 security mistakes people make with their mobile device
- iOS vs. Android: Which is more secure?
- 11 sure signs you've been hacked
- Face Time Anytime Real-time communications facilitates team collaboration from nearly anywhere in the world. With facts and figures you can use to justify an investment
- Riverbed Stingray Application Firewall: Securing Cloud Applications with a Distributed Web Application Firewall Responsibility over IT security is moving away from the network and IT infrastructure and to the application and software architecture itself. IT organizations...
- Now is the time to implement a video conference solution Video conferencing is getting a lot of buzz lately due to the recent cost decrease, making it tangible for many law firms. It's...
- Video drives engagement Achieving maximum results means building a solid platform and network infrastructure. As digital age unfolds, it's clear that the ability to communicate effectively...
- Meg Whitman presents Unlocking IT with Big Data During this Web Event you will hear Meg Whitman, President and CEO, HP discuss HAVEn - the #1 Big Data platform, as well...
- The New Way to Work Knowledge Vault This Knowledge Vault focuses on how, in today's increasingly virtual world, it's more important than ever to engage deeply with employees, suppliers, partners,... All Web Apps White Papers | Webcasts