Microsoft not so 'open' after all?
Head of open-source group says more than half of licenses don't pass muster
Computerworld - The head of the open-source group that will decide whether to certify Microsoft Corp.'s "shared source" software licenses as open-source licenses said that more than half of Redmond's licenses appear to automatically fail the group's rules.
Michael Tiemann, president of the non-profit Open Source Initiative, said that provisions in three out of five of Microsoft's shared-source licenses that restrict source code to running only on the Windows operating system would contravene a fundamental tenet of open-source licenses as laid out by the OSI. By those rules, code must be free for anyone to view, use, modify as they see fit.
"I am certain that if they say Windows-only machines, that would not fly because that would restrict the field of use," said Tiemann in an interview late Friday.
At the OSCON show in Portland last Thursday, Microsoft announced its plans to submit its shared-source licenses to the 9-year-old OSI for approval.
Microsoft did not immediately return a request for comment on which licenses it planned to submit to the OSI, or whether it plans to modify them beforehand.
"Microsoft will not be getting special treatment -- good or bad," he said. "They will get the same treatment we give Sun, IBM, SimpleText, or individuals that submit licenses -- fully transparent discussion that involves the community."
By his count, the OSI has rejected "two dozen" or so license applications for language that restricted the use or redistribution of software and its source code, even when the restrictions were written with what Tiemann called "moral" intent. For instance, the OSI has rejected license applications from Quakers and other pacifists who sought to prevent the use of software for weapons such as landmines.
"I am highly sympathetic to that point of view," he said. "But the OSI is not in the business of legislating moral use. We allow all use, commercial or non-commercial, mortal or medical."
The best-known open-source licenses approved by the OSI include the General Public License (GPL) used by Linux, which is currently being rewritten, as well as the Mozilla Public License used by the Firefox Web browser.
If approved, Microsoft would not be the first vendor not normally associated with open-source to have its licenses evaluated or approved by the OSI. Among the 50 software licenses certified by the OSI include licenses from vendors such as CA Inc., RealNetworks Inc., Nokia Corp, Sybase Inc., and Apple Inc.
- Move Mission-Critical Apps to the Cloud with AWS and F5 Read this paper to learn about adoption inhibitors of the cloud, potential solutions, and how advanced Application Delivery Controller (ADC) technologies are critical...
- The Principles of the Business Data Lake The Business Data Lake is a new approach to information management, analytics and reporting that better matches the culture of business and better...
- Start with a Data Lake. End with Business Value. Pivotal Big Data Suite enables companies to store all data, accelerate processing and most importantly increase the amount of data being analyzed and...
- Store Everything. Analyze Anything, Build the Right Thing. The value of Information has increased, so has the business's thirst for more information.
- Transform Your IT Service Management Watch this webinar, to learn how EasyVista can increase IT productivity & efficiency and deliver streamlined & integrated IT Service & Asset Mgmt.
- Responding to New SSL Cybersecurity Threat The featured Gartner research examines current strategies to address new SSL cybersecurity threats and vulnerabilities. All Applications White Papers | Webcasts