Ads by TechWords

See your link here
Receive the latest technology news and information.
Networking
Computerworld Daily News (First Look and Wrap-Up)
Computerworld Blogs Newsletter
The Weekly Top 10
Cloud Computing
View all newsletters




Privacy Policy
 

Judge overturns Internet child protection law

COPA, designed to protect minors, is too broad and vague, he says

March 22, 2007 12:00 PM ET

Computerworld - The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) today welcomed a decision (download PDF) by a federal judge to overturn a 1998 law that made it a crime for Web sites to offer sexually explicit material that could be accessed by minors.

"We think the court's decision reiterates that the government should not be in the business of censoring the Internet," said Aden Fine, senior staff attorney at the ACLU. "In the name of protecting children from harmful material, [the law] would have stopped adults from receiving a great deal of speech that is constitutionally protected. The court once again made it clear that Congress cannot do that."

U.S. District Judge Lowell Reed Jr. of the Eastern District of Pennsylvania yesterday threw out the Child Online Protection Act, (COPA) on the grounds that it was "impermissibly vague and overbroad." In issuing a permanent injunction against the law's enforcement, Reed said that -- despite the compelling interest by Congress in protecting children from sexually explicit material on the Web -- COPA violates an person's First and Fifth Amendment rights.

Enacted on Oct. 21, 1998, COPA provided for criminal and civil penalties against Web sites that failed to take adequate measures to prevent minors from accessing sexually explicit material. Under the law, sites with such content were required to verify the age of those accessing the material, via credit cards for instance, or some other proof of age. Site operators that failed to take such precautions were subject to fines of up to $50,000 and jail terms of up to six months.

The day after the law went into effect, several individuals and organizations, including the ACLU and online publications such as Sexual Health Network, Salon Media Group Inc., and Free Speech Media LLC, sought an injunction against enforcement of the law. A preliminary injunction was granted in February 1999 and upheld by the Supreme Court in February 2004.

Following the Supreme Court's decision, the case was sent back to Reed for fact finding to determine, among other things, whether Internet filtering technologies and other measures were more effective and less restrictive than COPA.

In his ruling yesterday, Reed said that the wording of the law was too ambiguous to be effective. He argued that it could be applied too broadly and would have allowed prosecutors to use COPA not only against pornographers but also against a wide variety of Web publishers.

"Such a widespread application of COPA would prohibit and undoubtedly chill a substantial amount of constitutionally protected speech for adults," he said.

Enforcing the law was also difficult because of the nature of the Internet, Reed said in his decision. "On the Internet, everyone is faceless and fairly anonymous. [Thus, the] Internet merchant has no viable method of determining whether an individual is 6, 12, 17 or 51 years old."



Jump to comments

COPA

Additional Resources

Microsoft
Here are some of the key reasons why you would want to run Unified Access Gateway with DirectAccess.
Microsoft
Review how one energy firm tightened protection and simplified IT work using business-ready security solutions.
Sybase
In this white paper, IDC analyzes the role of next-generation mobile enterprise platforms as organizations seek a more strategic deployment of mobile solutions.

Learn the important issues you must consider before starting your next mobility initiative. Get your mobility white paper from IDC now, compliments of Sybase.

What People Are Saying

White Papers & Webcasts

Death to PST Files
Download Now  

Business Process Framework Demo
Learn about Configurable Business Processes and Calculated Fields. Watch Now!

A Green Architectural Strategy That Puts IT in the Black
Levergage green computing across your data center. Read more now.  

Manager Experience Demo
Go beyond self-service solutions to perform more effectively. Watch Now.

Quantifying the Business Value of VMware View
Learn why you should invest in a centralized virtual desktop.  

Asia-Pacific Enterprise Network Solutions
Learn through this Webcast how your business can achieve reliability, performance and value in hard-to-reach locations within the Asia-Pacific region.

Mainsoft Webcast w/ Forrester Research: Drive SharePoint Adoption in Lotus Notes Shops
How can you drive mainstream user adoption of Microsoft SharePoint when your users rely on Lotus Notes?


IT Jobs