Warner chief calls Jobs' DRM fight 'without logic'
Bronfman rejects the idea of dumping copy protection for digital tunes
February 9, 2007 12:00 PM ETComputerworld - Warner Music CEO Edgar Bronfman yesterday rejected in no uncertain terms Apple Inc. CEO Steve Jobs' suggestion earlier this week that the major music label companies should abandon digital tunes copy protection.
Jobs' proposal, which the Apple executive floated on Tuesday in an open letter that called on the label companies to let users download tracks sans digital rights management (DRM) antipiracy protection, is "completely without merit," said Bronfman. His comments came in a Q&A portion of an earnings conference call yesterday.
"We advocate the continued use of DRM," said Bronfman. "The notion that music does not deserve the same protection as software, film, video games or other intellectual property, simply because there is an unprotected legacy product in the physical world, is completely without logic or merit."
Jobs said that Apple would drop its FairPlay DRM "in a heartbeat" if the major record labels would license their music without requiring copy protection schemes. In his letter, Jobs criticized the labels -- Warner, EMI, Sony and Universal -- for demanding DRM on music sold online at the same time that they sell billions of CDs containing unprotected tracks.
"So if the music companies are selling over 90% of their music DRM-free, what benefits do they get from selling the remaining small percentage of their music encumbered with a DRM system?" Jobs asked. "There appear to be none."
Bronfman was the first executive of a major recording company to publicly take on Jobs' idea. He urged Apple and the music industry to continue working together. "Frankly, manifestos in advance of those discussions is counter-productive," said Bronfman.
Related Discussion:
- Shark Bait: My problem$ with the ipod
- Ken Gagne: Steve Jobs, Slayer of DRM
- David Haskin: Steve Jobs and the end of DRM
- IT Blogwatch: Vista DRM Diatribe (and Cartman does Warcraft)
Read more about intellectual property and drm in Computerworld's Intellectual Property and DRM Knowledge Center.
Warner Music
Additional Resources



Learn the important issues you must consider before starting your next mobility initiative. Get your mobility white paper from IDC now, compliments of Sybase.
White Papers & Webcasts
e-Book: The Shortcut Guide to Business Security Measures Using SSL
This 45-page e-Book gives you the tools you need to detect security vulnerabilities, build an information security strategy, and plan your investment in...
Data in Action: Making the Planet Smarter
Register Now
10 things you really wished you had known about PDF Security, but they didn't tell you!
Access this resource, compliments of LockLizard, for a limited time only!
Information Leakage - the enemy is within
Access this white paper, courtesy of LockLizard, for a limited time only!
The Workday User Experience Video
Watch Workday's Creative Director, Scott Lietzke, discuss the business-centered design philosophy at Workday.
Adobe Acrobat PDF Security - a brief history of development
Access this resource, compliments of LockLizard, for a limited time only!
Business Process Framework Demo
Learn about Configurable Business Processes and Calculated Fields. Watch Now!
Oracle Accelerate - Not Just Smart but Timely
Download Now!
Manager Experience Demo
Go beyond self-service solutions to perform more effectively. Watch Now.

