Skip the navigation
Opinion

Wait! Don't buy Windows Vista!

Microsoft's new OS is the best Windows ever. But don't buy it!

By Mike Elgan
January 25, 2007 12:00 PM ET

Computerworld - Unless you've recently emerged from a coma, you know the consumer versions of Microsoft's new Vista operating system ship Tuesday. Over the next few weeks, NBA star LeBron James will try to convince you to move to Windows Vista as part of Microsoft's massive ad campaign.

This column is not a review of Windows Vista. I'm not here to tell you what's great about Vista or what's wrong with it.

This article is for those of you who are about to download or purchase Windows Vista and install it on a PC. I'm here to talk you out of it. Just say no to LeBron James and Windows Vista -- for now. Here's why.

1. Vista is incomplete

Microsoft is already planning its first service pack and seeking input from users on what to include. Vista probably won't be truly ready for prime time until that first service pack version, possibly later this year.

The hardware and software companies that make compatible products for Vista aren't all ready for the new operating system. Many of those companies are scrambling to complete Vista drivers and updates. Most importantly, not all video and sound card companies are ready.

Audio and peripheral maker Creative publishes a list detailing the status of drivers for each of its many products. Most of their Sound Blaster Internal products already have Vista drivers available. Two of them have only a "beta 2" version of the drivers. Three of their older products say "No Development Planned." Most of their cameras and other peripherals have no Vista-specific drivers available.

On the Advanced Micro Devices site, you can find information about Vista readiness of ATI graphics cards (AMD and ATI merged last year). Most are supported by a Catalyst Vista Software Driver, which is "beta," and are plagued by a long list of published "known issues." It also comes with the following warning: "ATI does NOT recommend installing these drivers in systems used for mission critical operations or where productivity of any kind is a concern."

These two companies are on the leading edge of supporting Vista. Their partial readiness for Vista is symptomatic for the larger companies. Many smaller peripheral makers simply have no Vista support at all.

At least OEMs, Alienware and Polywell, are aggressively pushing XP over Vista, because both say graphics and other drivers for Vista aren't quite ready for prime time.

Software, such as the security suites you may have already paid for, may not run on Vista, and some require updates that aren't ready yet.

Trend Micro, Panda, CA and Symantec all have announced that they'll ship updated suites on Tuesday -- just in time for the consumer availability of Vista.



mike elgan

Additional Resources
ESG - What's Needed for Cloud Computing
WHITE PAPER
Just what is cloud computing anyway? Skeptics might say it is nothing but industry hyperbole, visionaries might say it is the future of IT. In reality, both statements are true - cloud computing has been embellished by the tech industry but it does hold real potential for new types of on-demand dynamic IT services. This paper seeks to clarify the definition of cloud computing, identify how far along users are in terms of cloud deployment, and examine the role of the network in the cloud computing model.
Driving Storage Efficiency in SAN Environments
WHITE PAPER
This ESG paper outlines the considerations for architecting an efficient SAN data storage infrastructure with a focus on the NetApp solutions for increased utilization, improved performance and streamlined protection to reduce operational costs.
Get a Quick ROI from Being Green
WEBCAST
The menu of green initiatives is long, but how do you get an early win with a solid ROI? Enterprise Print Services address sustainability issues well beyond paper usage. Learn how you can get an assessment of enterprise printing to identify underutilized devices, reduce energy consumption, cut waste, and free-up valuable space.
What People Are Saying
Operating Systems White Papers
Windows Done Right: From Migration to Implementation
The recent IDC executive brief, "Doing Windows 7 Right: Efficiency from Migration to Implementation" offers a better understanding on how the migration to...
Lessons Learned from Windows 7 Early Adopters
According to Windows 7 early adopters, there are benefits to moving to Windows 7 sooner rather than later. But regardless of when you...
Red Hat Enterprise Linux: A Higher Value and Lower Cost Alternative
Read More about Red Hat's Alternative to Microsoft Windows Server 2008.
Linux and Solaris: An Analysis of Two Strategies
Read more about the analysis that aids in the selection of the most appropriate platform for enterprise environments
Strategic Migration Planning: Sun Solaris to Red Hat Enterprise Linux
Many of these organizations have chosen to migrate from proprietary technologies, such as Sun® Solaris®, to alternatives based on open standards like Red...
All Operating Systems White Papers
Operating Systems Webcasts
The Smart Route to Windows 7
Join IDC analyst Al Gillen as he presents findings from "Windows 7 Done Right: Efficiency from Migration to Implementation" to demonstrate how planning...
IDC Webcast: Linux Adoption in a Global Recession
Access this webcast, compliments of Novell and HP, for a limited time only!
Bringing Order and Security to your Mobile Workforce: Corporate Mobility Policy and Device Management
Download this webcast, free, compliments of Nokia.
Guiding Principles for Healthcare in Transformation
EMC Consulting has developed guiding principles for information technology in healthcare provider institutions. These aren't technical points. They're the kinds of guidelines that...
Desktop virtualization keys innovation drive
View now.
All Operating Systems Webcasts
IT Jobs