EFF: Patent ruling hurts open-source software
Inventors accuse ruling of burying, not saving, the system
IDG News Service - The Electronic Frontier Foundation has asked the Supreme Court to overturn a patent ruling, saying the way a lower court views patentable inventions could hurt free and open-source software projects.
The EFF filed a brief asking the Supreme Court to shoot down the so-called "suggestion test," a method the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has used to determine whether an invention should be obvious to others, and therefore, not patentable.
The appeals court, in several cases involving the combination of inventions, has declined to invalidate patents for obviousness, except when the court can find evidence of an earlier "suggestion" that the inventions could be combined.
The EFF argues the suggestion test makes it too easy to convince the appeals court an invention isn't obvious. The appeals court has forced district court judges to abandon their own scrutiny and "leave their brains at the courthouse door," EFF lawyers wrote in the brief filed in a gas-pedal patent case called KSR International Co. v. Teleflex Inc., which the Supreme Court has agreed to review in the coming year.
The suggestion test "has forced litigants to search through haystack upon haystack of technical knowledge for the exact needle in which someone, somewhere, bothers to state the obvious," the EFF continued.
The suggestion test has contributed to a "massive surge" in the number of patents granted, EFF lawyers wrote in the brief, made public Wednesday. The suggestion standard especially threatens free and open-source software (FOSS) projects, because they are created in the open, making it easier for others to steal the ideas and file patent claims, said Jason Schultz, an EFF staff attorney.
In addition, many FOSS projects don't have the financial resources to defend against patent claims, Schultz said. "In fact, the economic margins of many FOSS projects are so thin that the expensive legal costs associated with both acquiring or defending patents would, quite simply, put the projects out of business," the EFF wrote.
FOSS projects also tend to be loosely organized, and e-mail or message-board documentation may often not meet the evidence standards demanded by the appeals court, the EFF said.
"FOSS projects are less of a unified thing than most proprietary software companies," Schultz added. "They are scattered around and it's harder to track people and documents down sometimes."
FOSS advocates aren't alone in the tech industry in questioning the suggestion test. Microsoft Corp. and Cisco Systems Inc. were among the companies signing on to an earlier brief arguing the appeals court has been "too lenient" in accepting patents. The suggestion test hurts innovation by forcing companies to spend their resources on "defensive, large-scale patenting," the companies argued.
But others dispute that patents are too easy to obtain. Getting a single patent can cost thousands of dollars, said Stephen Wren, an independent inventor from St. Louis. "My experience for the last fifteen years has been that if anything patents are too hard to get -- not too easy," he said.
Large tech companies are trying to make it even more difficult for small inventors, he added. "This is but another effort by large multinationals and their henchmen parading as public interest groups to gut the patent system," Wren said of objections to the suggestion test. "They aren’t trying to fix it. They’re trying to bury it."
- Silicon Valley's 19 Coolest Places to Work
- Is Windows 8 Development Worth the Trouble?
- 8 Books Every IT Leader Should Read This Year
- 10 Hot Hadoop Startups to Watch
- Slideshow: 7 security mistakes people make with their mobile device
- iOS vs. Android: Which is more secure?
- 11 sure signs you've been hacked
- Logicalis eBook: SAP HANA: The Need for Speed Without timely business insights, organizations today can suffer logistical, manufacturing, and even financial disaster in a matter of minutes
- Neustar 2014 DDoS Attacks and Impact Report For the third consecutive year, Neustar surveyed hundreds of companies on distributed denial of service (DDoS) attacks. The survey reveals evidence that the...
- Acxiom Case Study This case study, which focuses on Acxiom, explores how the company was able to secure employee data, reduce migration costs and boost productivity...
- Windows® XP Migration: Protect and Secure Critical Data With the end of the Microsoft Windows XP operating system's lifecycle on April 8, 2014, businesses are faced with the decision to migrate...
- Live Webcast Best Practices: How to Improve Business Continuity with Virtualization VMware solutions include a range of business continuity capabilities to help ensure availability for applications across your virtualized environment. Learn More>>
- Live Webcast LIVE EVENT: 5/7, The End of Data Protection As We Know It. Introducing a Next Generation Data Protection Architecture. Traditional backup is going away, but where does this leave end-users?
- Live Webcast
Enhance Your Virtualization Infrastructure With IBM and Vmware
Date: Wednesday, May 14, 2014, 1:00 PM EDT
Virtualization technology is now expanding beyond the server compute elements to encompass networking and storage...
- Top 4 Digital Signage Fails Join RMG Networks for a look at four of the most common reasons digital signage fails in corporate businesses. Learn about strategies to...
- Building Tomorrow's Infrastructure Listen to this podcast to discover how Crider Foods worked with PC Connection to update their IT infrastructure, while maintaining compliance and control.