Court dismisses lawsuit in merchant data-breach case
The legal battle involved a 2004 data breach by BJ's Wholesale Club
Computerworld - Security analysts have for some time now been warning that companies could find themselves becoming targets of costly lawsuits for information security failures. But so far, at least, it has been mostly the plaintiffs who have lost the few cases taken to court.
The latest example is a U.S. District Court's decision late last week to throw out a lawsuit filed by the Pennsylvania State Employees Credit Union (PSECU) against Fifth Third Bancorp. of Cincinnati.
The Harrisburg-based PSECU hoped to recover $100,000 it spent on canceling and reissuing 235,000 Visa credit cards compromised in a security breach at BJ's Wholesale Club Inc., based in Natick, Mass., in 2004.
PSECU had argued that Fifth Third was liable for the costs because it was the bank responsible for processing card transactions for BJ's and should have ensured that the merchant was complying with Visa's security requirements.
PSECU's original lawsuit for breach of contract and negligence also included BJ's. But all of PSECU's claims against BJ's and three of its claims against Fifth Third bank were dismissed last October by the court in Harrisburg.
The same court threw out the one remaining claim against Fifth Third last Friday, saying that PSECU wasn't a third-party beneficiary to the contract between Fifth Third and Visa and was therefore not entitled to seek any card reissuance costs.
"PSECU is at most an incidental beneficiary of the member agreement between Visa and Fifth Third, but an incidental beneficiary has no right to enforce a contract," District Judge William Caldwell wrote in his opinion. "Needless to say, I'm disappointed with the court's ruling," PSECU President Greg Smith said in an e-mailed comment. "It's a little frustrating to know that PSECU was the one party in this situation that kept its word [and] honored its contracts, but when someone else didn't, we're still the one to pay."
As a result of the BJ's breach, Fifth Third has paid almost $900,000 in fraud-related charges to several credit card issuers, according to court documents.
"The court seems to be saying that the Visa system provides relief for issuers who suffered fraud losses, but Visa won't cover the costs of reissuing cards, which is the best defense against fraudulent charges," Smith said.
Stephanie Hagen, a spokeswoman for Fifth Third, said the bank does not comment on litigation issues.
The PSECU is one of several institutions that have filed claims over the BJ's breach. Others include CUNA Mutual Group, Sovereign Bank and Banknorth NA.
The case highlights how "there really is a high barrier for plaintiffs to bring these kind of lawsuits," said Ethan Preston, an attorney atKamber & Associates LLC in New York.
- The Pivotal Big Data Suite- Reducing the Risks of Big Data The explosion of big data and the rapid evolution of big data tools and technologies is challenging IT to meet the demands of...
- A Survival Guide for Data in the Wild All corporate data used to reside in the data center. Safe and sound behind the corporate firewall. But now, employees have multiple devices...
- Transforming Security: Designing a State-of-the-Art Extended Team The information security mission is no longer about implementing and operating controls.
- The Big Data Security Analytics Era Is Here New security risks and old security challenges often overwhelm legacy security controls and analytical tools.
- What should I look for in a Next Generation Firewall? SANS Provides Guidance With so many vendors claiming to have a Next Generation Firewall (NGFW), it can be difficult to tell what makes each one different....
- Responding to New SSL Cybersecurity Threat The featured Gartner research examines current strategies to address new SSL cybersecurity threats and vulnerabilities. All Security White Papers | Webcasts
Our new bimonthly Internet of Things newsletter helps you keep pace with the rapidly evolving technologies, trends and developments related to the IoT. Subscribe now and stay up to date!