Skip the navigation
)

LinuxWorld: A defiant IBM says Linux indemnification is unnecessary

It asserts that SCO's legal claims have no merit

By Todd R. Weiss
January 21, 2004 12:00 PM ET

Computerworld - NEW YORK -- Although Novell Inc., SUSE Linux AG, Sun Microsystems Inc., Hewlett-Packard Co. and Red Hat Inc. are all offering protection or indemnification programs to protect customers from possible legal threats stemming from their use of Linux, industry leader IBM has quietly remained on the sidelines.
But here at the opening day of the LinuxWorld Conference & Expo, IBM publicly weighed in on the issue at a product announcement news conference, arguing that there's really no need for it to indemnify its growing pool of 6,300 Linux customers. IBM's rationale: The ongoing $3 billion lawsuit filed against it last March by The SCO Group Inc. is baseless.
"Our position hasn't changed," said Jim Stallings, IBM's general manager for Linux. "The claims that have been alleged [by SCO] against IBM [have] no basis," so indemnification is not needed.
Even if customers still have concerns, both major Linux distributions -- SUSE Linux and Red Hat Enterprise Linux -- have customer protection programs in place to help defend users against legal actions from SCO, Stallings said. In addition, the Open Source Development Labs, a nonprofit enterprise Linux advocacy group, has begun a defense fund that it hopes will bring in $10 million for users entangled in any related legal fights.
Despite recent legal threats from SCO that it could soon begin suing enterprise Linux users, use of the operating system among businesses has continued to grow, Stallings said. "They voted," he said of customers who have deployed Linux. "Given what's there, customers have made up their minds by the thousands" and see SCO's legal challenge as baseless.
Irving Wladawsky-Berger, vice president of technology and strategy for IBM, reiterated Stallings' comments. Wladawsky-Berger said indemnification is unnecessary because no court has yet to rule on SCO's claims.
"We believe the [SCO] suit has zero merit," Wladawsky-Berger said. "In our legal system, you've got to go to court and get it over with. That's what we're doing.
"I know there is a part of the United States that believes that legal issues should be tried in the media," he said. "But it's not won in the media. We think the actions we're taking are the right actions to get these issues behind us."
Matt Plociak, an analyst at Progressive Strategies Inc. in New York, said IBM's argument against offering indemnification to its customers makes sense.
"To me, if you offer indemnification, you're saying there may be a problem," he said. "IBM is saying there is no problem and [that they're] going to prove that in court. I think that's a reasonable strategy, and obviously their customers are confident with that," because they haven't stopped buying and using Linux.
Al Gillen, an analyst at Framingham, Mass.-based IDC, said that while IBM continues to pass on indemnification, the company has donated money to the legal defense fund created by the Beaverton, Ore.-based OSDL. "I don't think there's any real need to provide any indemnification until they have a customer who's in some form of litigation" in connection with SCO's claims, Gillen said. "Then the pressure would increase for them to do something."
Yesterday, Red Hat announced the creation of a new Open Source Assurance program that will protect all existing and future Red Hat Enterprise Linux customers from legal challenges as long as they're using the software (see story). Under the included Intellectual Property Warranty, the company would replace any software code that allegedly infringed on other code, so users and developers could continue to work with the products. Money would be available from the Open Source Now legal defense fund for customers that might be sued for infringement issues.
The Red Hat move comes on the heels of last week's decision by Novell, which just acquired SUSE Linux, to indemnify SUSE Linux customers against possible legal action from SCO (see story).
When Unix vendor SCO filed its lawsuit against IBM, it alleged that IBM had illegally contributed some of SCO's System V Unix code to the open source Linux project. Additional suits and countersuits have been filed by Red Hat and Novell since the case began.




Read more about Linux and Unix in Computerworld's Linux and Unix Topic Center.



What is Tech Briefcase?
TechBriefcase is a new, free service where IT Professionals can Search, Store and Share IT white papers and content like this. Learn more
Bookmark content
Speed up your research efforts with content across the web.
Search and Store
Find the white papers you need. Create folders for any topic.
View Anywhere
Open your briefcase on your iPhone, tablet or desktop. Share with colleagues.
Don't have an account yet?
Additional Resources
Security KnowledgeVault
WHITE PAPER
Security is not an option. This KnowledgeVault Series offers professional advice how to be proactive in the fight against cybercrimes and multi-layered security threats; how to adopt a holistic approach to protecting and managing data; and how to hire a qualified security assessor. Make security your Number 1 priority.

Read now.

Cut Communications Costs Once and for All
WHITE PAPER
New IP-based communications systems are being deployed by small and midsized businesses at a rapid rate. Learn how these organizations are enabling faster responsiveness, creating better customer experiences, speeding office or mobile interactions, and dramatically reducing existing communications costs.

Read now.

Topic Center White Papers
Practice Management: Double Billing Rate and Improve Patient Services
Would you like to double your billing rate and achieve faster payment for services?

Download this customer success story to see how One Health...
Mission Critical Data Explosion and Customer Case Study
Would you like to double your tier 1 storage capacity while simultaneously reducing your storage footprint?

Download this customer success story to see how...
Protecting Against Database Attacks and Insider Threats: Top 5 Scenarios
Read this new eBook to learn the top five scenarios and essential best practices for preventing database attacks and insider threats.
Database Activity Monitoring Is Evolving
Read the analyst report and learn how you can leverage the core capabilities of a DAP solution for better database security.
Establishing a Strategy for Database Security is No Longer Optional
The options for securing increasingly valuable databases are very broad and deep, and can be confusing. This research provides an overview of three...
All Topic Center White Papers
Topic Center Webcasts
Live Webcast
Data Privacy and Protection in Production Environments: New Research from Ponemon Institute
Date: Wednesday, June 13, 2012, 1:00 PM EDT / 10:00 AM PDT

In a recent study conducted by Ponemon Institute, fifty-five percent of respondents...
Live Webcast
A Geek's Guide to Presenting to Business People
Live Webcast: Wednesday, June 20th at 1:00 PM EDT

Join this live webinar with Paul Glen, author of Leading Geeks, to learn how to...
Live Webcast
Today's NAS: A Solution Beyond Old Limits
Date: Tuesday, July 17, 2012 2:00 PM EDT

Traditional NAS systems don't scale beyond fixed limits. Proliferation of NAS systems leads to management...
Distributed Database Security with Real-time Monitoring
View this demo and learn how IBM InfoSphere Guardium database activity monitoring can help protect your sensitive data in distributed DBMS environments with...
InfoSphere Warehouse Packs Demo
These flash modules make warehousing more tangible and relevant to business users through detailed explanations of the InfoSphere Warehouse Packs.
Delivery Management -- Extending Lifecycle Management
Date: Wednesday, June 20, 2012, 1:00 PM EDT

Siloed organizations continue doing the wrong things and doing things wrong, leading to increased costs,...
Leverage automation today to reduce IT complexity
Date: Tuesday, June 5, 2012, 2:00 PM EDT

Whether your B2B complexity is caused by multiple technologies due to M&A, business or application specific...
Redefine Expectations in the Data Center
Need to do more with less? Watch this video to learn how HP ProLiant Gen8 servers can help your business deploy servers three...
All Topic Center Webcasts
Newsletter Sign-Up

Receive the latest news test, reviews and trends on your favorite technology topics

Choose a newsletter
  1. View all newsletters | Privacy Policy
IT Jobs