Sidebar: Users, vendors debate merits of open-source Java
Computerworld -
Some prominent vendors that work on Java standards through Sun Microsystems Inc.'s community process favor Java going open-source. Many corporate developers, however, have divergent opinions on the matter, and some said they think Sun's Java Community Process (JCP) is working out just fine for the evolving technology.
A sampling of the range of opinions follows:
Favor current JCP
Mark Jeffrey, senior programmer/analyst, Anteon Corp., Fort Detrick, Md.: "At this point in time, I don't see moving it to open-source. I think it's fine the way it is. Once you make it open-source, you lose a lot of the control of the security features that are built into Java. From a programming standpoint, it's nice that Java has all these security features built into it."
Trevor Gaffney, programmer/analyst, Choice Hotels International Inc., Phoenix: "I think the community process works fine. Open-source may slow things down a bit because there are too many hands in the cookie jar."
Aaron Jennings, software engineer, Lockheed Martin Air Traffic Management, a unit of Lockheed Martin Corp. in Rockville, Md.: "I think they're doing a good job with the JCP, and now that they're opening the JCP to more people, it's heading in the right direction. If they were to move to full open-source, there could be issues with bringing open-source into these highly designed APIs [application programming interfaces]. We need more stringent control on what the final release of the API is."
Chris Logan, application architect, Iron Mountain Inc., Boston: "The impetus for the maturation of Java is Sun's desire to be a profitable company. If Java goes open-source, I'm not sure what the impetus would be to mature the platform. I'd be afraid of anything so big going open-source."
Mixed reactions
Michael Bechauf, vice president, Java architecture and standards, SAP Labs LLC: "From an innovation point of view, it certainly would be beneficial. A lot of good ideas come out of the open-source initiatives. But you can't use open-source as a model for standardization or developing reference implementations."
Favor open-source
Clement Gomez, senior software engineer, The American Red Cross, Falls Church, Va.: "I think [open-source] helps develop the language. The conversion of ideas makes it better."
Lawrence Anderson, manager of enterprise engineering, enterprise technology services, The American Red Cross, Falls Church, Va.: "For all intents and purposes, Sun has a major control over Java ... Sun loses if Java becomes open-source, because people can pick and choose the best pieces [of software], and they're not the leader in any of these spaces.
"I'm worried
Web Services
Additional Resources



White Papers & Webcasts
Maximizing website Return on Information with high-quality search
Download this whitepaper explaining how an investment in site search can boost your earnings while reducing customer service costs.
Key Strategies for Managing Data Growth
What are you storage challenges?
Red Hat Continues to Redefine SOA: SIMPLE. OPEN. AFFORDABLE.
SOA enables enterprises to accelerate business execution while driving higher quality and customer satisfaction.
Extending Client Refresh - 11 Steps to Maximize Savings
Register Now!
Open Source Middleware Reference Architecture
A roadmap of open source software capabilities across a diverse set of application requirements.
Lower the Cost and Complexity of a Mobile Workforce through Automation
Download This Resource Now!
Understanding the Business Benefits of an Open Source SOA Platform
Address the serious business challenges that SOA helps to overcome.
Managing Mobility: Improve Data Security, Compliance and Manageability
Download This Resource Now!
Enterprise Acceleration
Best practices to help IT developers become more productive.
Consolidate Your Servers and Storage to Lower Costs with Oracle Database 11g
Register for this webcast!
