Q&A: The X Factor
Computerworld - Long before Microsoft Corp. ever contemplated Terminal Services, the X Window System set the standard for thin-client computing. Originally developed at MIT as part of Project Athena, X remains the predominant thin-client standard for Linux and Unix applications. Computerworld asked Steve Swales, chairman of X.org and a senior manager at Sun Microsystems Inc. about the strengths and limitations of the standard -- and how it will evolve.
Q: Why use X Window?
A: It's the only choice right now for Unix and Linux for desktop applications. X is the only window system that's designed to be networked on the inside. It provides [support for] accelerated graphics hardware on the desktop. You lose that with the other kinds of [thin-client] systems. Many corporations are using it internally to deploy [computer-aided design] applications to workstations.
Q: Why not X?
A: Some would say it's complex to deploy. Part of the reason X terminals didn't catch on was the complexity of administering them. But some companies have wrapped it up and made it easy to install on a PC.
Q: Why not X over the Internet?
A: A few years back, there were efforts to push X over the Internet. "Web-enabled X" was the code name for that. But it's almost unused. The implementation is difficult to set up, [and] there are some security issues. The technology lets you take anything on your X screen and shove it out through a Web page.
It's a little bit confusing. You have to have a Java [virtual machine] on the machine where the browser is and an X server on that local machine to have the X technology work. The browser is not actually acting as an X server; it's just connecting to the X server and allowing X applications to safely display within the browser. It's confusing, and it's one of the reasons that the technology hasn't become very popular.
Q: How about X for remote office connectivity?
A: It wasn't designed for particularly low-bandwidth networks. For an individual user running over a dial-up line, you need to have some kind of compression in place.
There is an extension in place to provide a low-bandwidth implementation called LBX [low-bandwidth X]. Hummingbird has implemented that. Companies like Boeing are deploying it.
Q: X Window was in many ways the original thin-client standard. Why hasn't it seen even broader adoption?
A: A lot of it had to do with the history of X Window. The stewards of X really dribbled away to almost nothing about five or six years ago. It wasn't really keeping pace with the technology.
Q: What's next for X?
A:There's quite a lot of work happening in the area of enhancing the rendering capability to handle higher-resolution displays and high-quality text rendering. We're working on exciting technology for carrying the audio visual technology along with the X connection.
Read more about App Development in Computerworld's App Development Topic Center.
- Real-Time Application-Centric Operations Visibility with NetScout's Approach to Service Delivery Management This ENTERPRISE MANAGEMENT ASSOCIATES whitepaper examines the move towards application/service performance visibility within IT operations
- Architects lead the next generation of data-driven applications Read this whitepaper to find out how application architects can quickly and confidently deliver long-lasting applications that minimize cost, complexity, and risk while...
- Gartner 2013 ALM Magic Quadrant Report This Gartner Group report is a must-read to gain a better understanding of the automated software quality assurance market today.
- Finding agility in the age of applications This white paper reveals how to extend Agile throughout the enterprise and make your business more nimble.
- Live Webcast How to serve up a Grand Slam with a scalable IT Infrastructure for cloud, big data and advanced analytics Register today to attend this webcast, and see examples of how The U.S. Tennis Association, Wimbledon and U.S. Golf Association are using the...
- Top 4 Digital Signage Fails Join RMG Networks for a look at four of the most common reasons digital signage fails in corporate businesses. Learn about strategies to...
- Mastering the Art of Mobile Content Management Mobile device usage in the enterprise has skyrocketed in recent years, and it continues to escalate.