Never, ever agree to 'evergreen' clauses
DRIVING THE DEAL
March 6, 2000 12:00 PM ET
Vendors know that information technology professionals don't manage contracts very well. As a result, many of the form contracts that vendors use contain an "evergreen" clause. This clause provides for the automatic extension of the agreement if the vendor isn't notified by a certain date a few years down the road, when no one has seen the contract for a while or there are new people in charge of the project for which the deal was done. When challenged about the clause, the vendor usually responds by stating that it "just makes things easy."
It sure does -- for the vendors. They almost always get an automatically extended stream of revenue, sometimes called "easy money."
Vendors describe an automatic renewal as a customer convenience. They argue that it prevents service lapses and eliminates an administrative burden for you. The unmentioned risk is that you might be paying for a service you no longer need. But the reality is that a lifetime of administrative effort required to renew contracts is more than paid for if just one unwanted automatic renewal is prevented.
What's more, conditions and requirements change rapidly today. Automatic renewals pre-empt making choices. You should have the right to renew -- but not the unexpected obligation.
Hand-in-hand with automatic renewal is price- increase language. One of the biggest scams is in software maintenance and support. It's not at all uncommon to see annual increases of 15% to 20% year after year and automatic renewals of the contract terms. So require vendors to notify you when maintenance is about to lapse and tell them to ask if you want to renew -- at a not-to-exceed price you both agree to at the start of the contract. This approach creates an opportunity to take stock of the situation, make a prudent decision and maybe even do some negotiating.
Always take the "never, ever evergreen" approach and you will be better for it.
Helping the Deal Initiators
It's great when your company's professional deal-makers know how to acquire IT products and services properly -- when they have the right experience and tools and understand the negotiation process. But when they haven't enlightened the people who initiate the deals, they've lost much of the opportunity to get the best deal. Many "best practices" procurement organizations actually "sell" their services to the deal initiators, noting benefits they will provide when called upon for help early.
What normally happens is that at the levels where deals actually begin -- with the technical analyst or project
IT Management
Additional Resources



White Papers & Webcasts
Extending Client Refresh - 11 Steps to Maximize Savings
Register Now!
3 Minutes with Free Tool Can Save Thousands!
Register Now!
Consolidate Your Servers and Storage to Lower Costs with Oracle Database 11g
Register for this webcast!
Looking for a fast payback?
Register Now!
The Commercialization of ITIL: Lessons Learned
Register for this event today!
Business Continuity - Are You Always Open for Business?
Download Now!
Key Findings: Accelerating ROI with BPM
Click here to watch now!
