Web publisher sues over exclusion from Google index
KinderStart.com says online business dropped dramatically after it was cut
IDG News Service - Google Inc. got hit with a lawsuit on Friday by a Web publisher that alleges it has suffered significant financial harm because its site got dropped from the search engine's index.
KinderStart.com Inc., which operates a Web site for parents of children under 7 years old, filed its lawsuit as a class action in U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, San Jose Division.
Norwalk, Calif.-based KinderStart.com has charged Google with, among other things, violating its right to free speech under the U.S. Constitution, violating Section 2 of the Sherman Antitrust Act by using a monopoly position to harm competitors, engaging in unfair practices and competition under California law, and committing defamation and libel.
The Web publisher is asking the court to certify the lawsuit as a class action nationwide with a subclass in California and award unspecified damages to affected businesses. It also wants the court to declare Google in violation of the plaintiffs' right to free speech and impose "suitable" injunctive relief for them.
If KinderStart.com prevails, the lawsuit could have significant repercussions on the way Google decides to remove Web sites from its index -- an action that can seriously hurt a business's sales and marketing operations because of Google's enormous influence on Web traffic as the world's most-used search engine.
Google reserves the right to remove Web sites from its index for various reasons. For example, in its webmaster guidelines for making a Web site easy for Google's search spider to crawl and index, the company lists practices Google considers deceptive that can get a site banned.
But KinderStart.com stated that it hasn't knowingly violated any of Google's webmaster guidelines. It is seeking class-action status for the lawsuit because it believes that a significant number of Web publishers have been affected in a similar way.
KinderStart.com launched its Web site in May 2000 and at its peak generated more than 10 million page views per month, according to the complaint. In 2003, the company also enrolled in Google's AdSense program, carrying ads distributed by Google and getting a commission whenever its visitors clicked on them.
Starting in March and April 2005, the Web site suffered a "cataclysmic" fall in traffic of about 70% and a drop in AdSense revenue of about 80%, from which it hasn't recovered and which the company blames on its removal from the Google index.
Prior to March 2005, Google was the top referring site for KinderStart.com, but today it accounts for less than 0.01% of referrals. KinderStart.com claims that it has never been notified by phone, mail or in person of the reason for its Web site's exclusion.
In a statement, Google called the lawsuit meritless and said it will defend itself vigorously.
Google's practice of banning sites from its index gained attention in February, when the company announced that it had decided to remove the German Web site of carmaker BMW for allegedly trying to deceive the Google search robot to gain higher placement. Days later, Google reinstated the site to its index, saying BMW had undone the offending changes, although BMW strongly objected to Google's characterization of its practices as misleading.


- Excel 2010 Cheat Sheet
- Register for this Computerworld Insider Cheat Sheet and gain access to hundreds of premium content articles, guides, product reviews and more.
- Enabling Remote Employees with High Quality Video
- In this paper, we analyze the delivery of live and on-demand mobile video content. It focuses on specific ways in which organizations can...
- Switching Schedulers - Not As Complicated As You Think
- Changing or consolidating job schedulers may seem daunting. However, the benefits of switching to enterprise workload automation outweigh the risks. Read how BMC...
- A "YouTube-like" Experience For Employees
- Leading research firms are predicting that video is becoming a key component of workplace collaboration. More and more, employees are creating and sharing...
- The CFO Guide to Budgeting Software
- A mid-sized business needs the same financial performance control and measurement capabilities as a large corporation, but in a solution that's affordable, easy...
- Transition from Spreadsheet Budgets to Packaged Application
- This white paper details the problems that go with spreadsheet-based budgeting as well as the advantages of packaged applications. It also proposes a...
- Live Webcast
How to Reduce Complexity and Automate Your Partners for Efficient E-Business: - Date: Tuesday, June 5, 2012, 2:00 PM EDT
Whether your B2B complexity is caused by multiple technologies due to M&A, business or application specific... - Live Webcast
Data Privacy and Protection in Production Environments: New Research from Ponemon Institute - Date: Wednesday, June 13, 2012, 1:00 PM EDT / 10:00 AM PDT
In a recent study conducted by Ponemon Institute, fifty-five percent of respondents... - Live Webcast
A Geek's Guide to Presenting to Business People - Live Webcast: Wednesday, June 20th at 1:00 PM EDT
Join this live webinar with Paul Glen, author of Leading Geeks, to learn how to... - BMC Control-M - Single Point of Control Demo
- With BMC Control-M, you schedule and manage everything - down to the very last platform and application - from one simple interface. It's...
- Operational Analytics - Changing the Competitive Dynamics of the Business
- Date/Time: June 5, 2012, 11:00 a.m., EDT, 4:00 p.m. BST / 3:00 p.m. UTC
Please join us for this webcast, as Dr. Barry... - Oracle Database Appliance Best Practices
- Business users increasingly demand 24x7 availability of their data while IT departments face the challenge of ensuring maximum availability while operating with limited...
- BMC Control-M - Single Point of Control Demo
- With BMC Control-M, you schedule and manage everything - down to the very last platform and application - from one simple interface. It's...
- Sun Chemical Customer Success Story
- Sun Chemical, the world's largest producer of printing inks and pigments, quadrupled its complex batch environment with zero extra headcount using BMC Control-M's...