Ads by TechWords

See your link here
Receive the latest technology news and information.
IT Management
Computerworld Daily News (First Look and Wrap-Up)
Computerworld Blogs Newsletter
The Weekly Top 10
Cloud Computing
View all newsletters




Privacy Policy
 

Agile programming has fallen short, conference attendees told

March 14, 2006 12:00 PM ET

InfoWorld - Agile software development, which aims to offer a much quicker style of delivering software than traditional methods, has not yet met its promise, said Steve McConnell, author and chief software engineer at Construx Software Builders Inc., who spoke to attendees at the SD West 2006 conference in Santa Clara, Calif., on Monday.

Presenting on the best and worst ideas in software development, McConnell noted what appears to be a contradiction in agile programming so far. While intended to focus on individuals and interactions, agile programming seems to be mostly about processes and tools now, he said.

"It seems to me that the promise of agile development has fallen short at least so far," McConnell said.

After his presentation, McConnell said there has been excessive enthusiasm about agile programming, but this has happened before with other new technologies, such as computer-aided software engineering.

Agile programming was discussed during one of McConnell's worst-idea items: Software practices are based on the assumption that developers are omniscient and can know all requirements before building an architecture. He cited the traditional waterfall methodology as being based on this faulty assumption.

McConnell's best ideas included the following items:

  • Companies should recognize that software development is performed by human beings and that personnel capabilities are critical in software projects.
  • Iteration and incrementalism in software development are essential.
  • The cost of fixing defects increases over time.
  • Software projects tend to follow a predictable intellectual flow.
  • The ability to create accurate software estimates can be improved over time.
  • The most powerful form of reuse is full reuse.
  • Risk management provides critical insight into many software development issues. McConnell cited extrinsic risk management activities, which are bolted onto a project, and intrinsic activities, such as project tracking and UI prototyping.
  • Different kinds of software call for different kinds of software development.
  • A software engineering body of knowledge (SWEBOK) exists, featuring disciplines such as configuration management, maintenance and testing. "I'm not convinced [SWEBOK is the ultimate answer]," McConnell said. "I think it's a very good start, though."

The other worst ideas in software development cited by McConnell included:

  • There are only two development options: iterate everything and iterate nothing (the waterfall model).
  • Agile projects are immune to DCI (defect cost increase) dynamics. "The software engineering research really does not bear out this idea," McConnell said.
  • We have to accept "wickedness" in software projects since software projects are for wicked problems.
  • Requirements are always changing. "[The] single most common source of changing requirements [is] requirements that were not significantly investigated in the first place," said McConnell.
  • Requirements can be gathered or they just drop out of the sky like manna from heaven.
  • Entrepreneurial companies cannot be afraid of risk.
  • One single development approach will work best for all projects.
  • McConnell acknowledged that some of the content was not groundbreaking. "A lot of what I'm going to be saying this afternoon probably is not new. In fact some of it is . . . old," he said.

Audience member Prabhu Raghavan, project engineer at Stryker Endoscopy, said he had read some of McConnell's books and liked the presentation's emphasis on recognizing that not all code is the same. Risk management pointers also struck a chord.

"I like the [the idea of] identifying risks," Raghavan said.


Reprinted with permission from

For more enterprise computing news, visit Infoworld.com
Story copyright 2006 InfoWorld Media Group, Inc. All rights reserved.

Jump to comments

Development

Additional Resources

Microsoft
Here are some of the key reasons why you would want to run Unified Access Gateway with DirectAccess.
Microsoft
Review how one energy firm tightened protection and simplified IT work using business-ready security solutions.
Sybase
In this white paper, IDC analyzes the role of next-generation mobile enterprise platforms as organizations seek a more strategic deployment of mobile solutions.

Learn the important issues you must consider before starting your next mobility initiative. Get your mobility white paper from IDC now, compliments of Sybase.

IT Jobs

 

Putting the Right Model in Place to Better Balance IT Supply and Business Demand
IT leaders manage business demands and IT resources in many ways, but which methods are most effective? Tom Welsh, senior consultant of Cutter Consortium, compares two approaches and outlines their pros and cons in this Compuware-commissioned white paper. Get objective appraisals and real-world examples for both.

Download this white paper 
CIO best practices: Optimizing your Project Portfolio Management solution for greater business value
A Project Portfolio Management discipline goes beyond ordinary project management to link IT with the business and help IT leaders better understand the benefits, cost, risks and value of all projects. Download this Compuware white paper and learn how to boost the business value of your IT organization.

Download this white paper 
Exclusive eBook: Six Project Metrics Every CIO Should Know for Application Delivery Success
Most IT organizations spend their time measuring whether projects are on time or on budget. Read this IT executive guide to learn what key data tells you the degree of quality, client satisfaction and how well requirements were met. Make these metrics part of your overall application delivery management process - and your software can't fail.

Download this eBook 
IT Planning and Control: Unveiling the Interrelationships between ALM and PPM
Listen in as Gartner Analyst Matt Light discusses two hot topics-- Project Portfolio Management and Application Life-cycle Management--and how you can bring these disciplines together to improve application quality and delivery. Get recommendations on merging the two methods and learn what type of results you can expect.

Download this podcast