 
  See your link here
|
For more info on a specific newsletter, click the title. Details will be displayed in a new window.
Subscribe to
Computerworld 40 years of the most authoritative source of news and information for IT leaders.
IBM now faces fewer claims in SCO legal fight
or
Other Standards and Legal Issues Stories
|
|
|
|
July 04, 2006 (IDG News Service) -- A judge has tossed out almost 200 of The SCO Group Inc.'s claims of intellectual property violation against IBM on the grounds that SCO didn't identify the alleged infringements in enough detail.
In a 39-page ruling last week, Judge Brooke Wells of the U.S. District Court in Utah chastised SCO for its "willful failure" to identify exactly which parts of the software distributed by IBM allegedly infringe on SCO's intellectual property.
"SCO's arguments are akin to SCO telling IBM, 'Sorry we are not going to tell you what you did wrong because you already know,'" Wells wrote, saying its actions were prejudicial to IBM.
IBM had asked for 201 of SCO's 294 claims of intellectual property violation to be dropped before trial. After some clarifications, IBM continued to press for 198 claims to be dropped. The judge threw out all but about a dozen of those claims -- not based on their merits, she noted, but because of SCO's failure to specify for IBM the source code in question. Her order stemmed from an IBM motion to preclude SCO's claims from the case.
"Striking out such a large number was predictable in terms of what we've seen through this whole process, which is complete disability [on SCO's part] to produce evidence," said Gary Barnett, a U.K.-based software and intellectual property analyst with Ovum Ltd. "Undoubtedly it's bad for SCO's case, but it was pretty bad even before this happened."
SCO filed its lawsuit in 2003, arguing that IBM misappropriated portions of SCO's copyrighted Unix System V software code and contributed them to the Linux operating system. IBM has denied any wrongdoing and questioned the validity of SCO's copyrights.
A SCO spokesman said that the company's attorneys are reviewing the court's latest ruling. "They're planning what their next steps will be...," the spokesman said.
IBM spokesman John Charlson declined to comment, saying the company doesn't discuss pending litigation.
IBM will likely challenge those claims when the case comes to trial, Ovum's Barnett said. That's expected to happen early next year.
SCO had argued that it was sufficient for it to have identified the "methods and concepts" that it says were misappropriated by IBM. Wells disagreed, saying SCO should have identified the specific source code as well.
In siding with IBM, Wells drew a colorful analogy based on the Neiman Marcus department store.
"Certainly if an individual was stopped and accused of shoplifting after walking out of Neiman Marcus they would expect to be eventually told what they allegedly stole," she wrote. "It would be absurd for an officer to tell the accused that 'You know what you stole I’m not telling.' Or, to simply hand the accused individual a catalog of Neiman Marcus’ entire inventory and say 'It's in there somewhere, you figure it out.'
"Without more specificity than SCO has provided, some very important questions that could materially impact this case are nearly impossible to answer. For example, is the code that comprised the method or concept still in use in Linux? If not, then damages may become nominal instead of in the billions."
A copy of the ruling was posted on the Groklaw Web site.
Computerworld's Todd R. Weiss contributed to this report.
Reprinted with permission from
For more news from IDG visit IDG.netStory copyright 2006 International Data Group. All rights reserved.
|
Print this Story |
|
Send Us Feedback |
|
E-mail this Story |
|
Digg this Story |
|
Slashdot this Story |
|
|
|
|
 |
|
All Zones Application Performance Zone Enterprise-Class Security Zone Enterprise Solutions Zone The File Data Management Zone Grid Computing on Windows Zone Security Management Zone ITIL Best Practices Zone The SAS Zone Storage Virtualization Zone The Data Center Management Zone |
 |
||||||||
| ||||||||
| ||||||||
| ||||||||
|
Long Tail Supplier Collaboration - What's In It For You? 
Download this Executive Bulletin (a $49.95 value) for free, compliments of MessageLabs.
Get this white paper now!
Read up on the latest ideas and technologies from companies that sell hardware, software and services.
- Microsoft to limit capabilities of cheap laptops
- FBI worried as DoD sold counterfeit networking gear
- Update: Microsoft to appeal $1.3B EU fine
- More top stories
Security Management ZoneSecurity management is the process of developing a comprehensive data protection plan. It takes into account all potential threats, the existing network environment, the future needs of the organization, and lays out a multi-tiered blueprint to integrate the security technology needed to combat these threats. CDW can help keep your network and data secure. Visit the CDW Security Management Zone now See All Zones
|
| Try Fluke Networks' OptiView Analyzer on your network FREE Solve network and application issues, manage infrastructure changes and deploy new applications and services. Use OptiView Analyzer on your own network for five days at no charge. Generate network discovery reports, perform security audits of your network to find unauthorized devices and applications and see protocol distribution to eliminate legacy protocols. Request free trial now
|
 |
 |
Layered Security Solutions
Although basic network security issues have changed very little over the past decade, the
network security landscape has changed dramatically. Today's IT professionals still have the
primary responsibility of protecting the confidentiality of corporate information, preventing
unauthorized access, and defending the network against attacks. Security experts and analysts agree that a security solution comprised of multiple layers is the best defense against today's increasingly sophisticated attacks.Download this white paper
|
Universal Threat Management - Because Conventional UTM is Not Enough!
This white paper, written by Mark Bouchard of Missing Link Security Services, examines the challenges confronting today's enterprises with respect to managing threats on a network. It also discusses the need for "Universal Threat Management", which is a security solution approach for all physical locations within an enterprise that require threat protection.Download this white paper |
Selecting the Right Threat Management Solution
This short demo will guide you through key considerations for selecting a solution to manage threats on a network. Learn about the popularity of Unified Threat Management (UTM), and how it fits into an overall security solution. Explore critical elements of a network-wide solution for multisite and large network-size deployments and identify the four key features of a threat management solution.View this demo
|
