Agile programming has fallen short, conference attendees told

Paul Krill   Today’s Top Stories   or  Other Development Stories  

Get a Grip on Storage Growth and Reduce Costs What's Next? Real Answers for Tough Times Dynamic Data Center and Virtualization Drives Operational Excellence at Emory Healthcare Six Project Metrics Every CIO Should Know for Application Delivery Success Project Portfolio Management - Boost the value of IT Putting the Right Model in Place to Better Balance IT Supply and Business Demand Computerworld Report- Large Enterprises Pay More for IPAM An Apple for Your Enterprise? Six Questions To Ask About Information And Competition Sign up to receive Project Management Resource Alerts

March 14, 2006 (InfoWorld) -- Agile software development, which aims to offer a much quicker style of delivering software than traditional methods, has not yet met its promise, said Steve McConnell, author and chief software engineer at Construx Software Builders Inc., who spoke to attendees at the SD West 2006 conference in Santa Clara, Calif., on Monday.

Presenting on the best and worst ideas in software development, McConnell noted what appears to be a contradiction in agile programming so far. While intended to focus on individuals and interactions, agile programming seems to be mostly about processes and tools now, he said.

"It seems to me that the promise of agile development has fallen short at least so far," McConnell said.

After his presentation, McConnell said there has been excessive enthusiasm about agile programming, but this has happened before with other new technologies, such as computer-aided software engineering.

Agile programming was discussed during one of McConnell's worst-idea items: Software practices are based on the assumption that developers are omniscient and can know all requirements before building an architecture. He cited the traditional waterfall methodology as being based on this faulty assumption.

McConnell's best ideas included the following items:

• Companies should recognize that software development is performed by human beings and that personnel capabilities are critical in software projects.
• Iteration and incrementalism in software development are essential.
• The cost of fixing defects increases over time.
• Software projects tend to follow a predictable intellectual flow.
• The ability to create accurate software estimates can be improved over time.
• The most powerful form of reuse is full reuse.
• Risk management provides critical insight into many software development issues. McConnell cited extrinsic risk management activities, which are bolted onto a project, and intrinsic activities, such as project tracking and UI prototyping.
• Different kinds of software call for different kinds of software development.
• A software engineering body of knowledge (SWEBOK) exists, featuring disciplines such as configuration management, maintenance and testing. "I'm not convinced [SWEBOK is the ultimate answer]," McConnell said. "I think it's a very good start, though."

The other worst ideas in software development cited by McConnell included:

• There are only two development options: iterate everything and iterate nothing (the waterfall model).
• Agile projects are immune to DCI (defect cost increase) dynamics. "The software engineering research really does not bear out this idea," McConnell said.
• We have to accept "wickedness" in software projects since software projects are for wicked problems.
• Requirements are always changing. "[The] single most common source of changing requirements [is] requirements that were not significantly investigated in the first place," said McConnell.
• Requirements can be gathered or they just drop out of the sky like manna from heaven.
• Entrepreneurial companies cannot be afraid of risk.
• One single development approach will work best for all projects.
• McConnell acknowledged that some of the content was not groundbreaking. "A lot of what I'm going to be saying this afternoon probably is not new. In fact some of it is . . . old," he said.

Audience member Prabhu Raghavan, project engineer at Stryker Endoscopy, said he had read some of McConnell's books and liked the presentation's emphasis on recognizing that not all code is the same. Risk management pointers also struck a chord.

"I like the [the idea of] identifying risks," Raghavan said.

Reprinted with permission from

For more enterprise computing news, visit Infoworld.com
Story copyright 2006 InfoWorld Media Group, Inc. All rights reserved.

Print this Story

Send Us Feedback

E-mail this Story

Digg this Story

Slashdot this Story

"From the Professional Ruby Conference: An enterprise Rails host has a project in the works to simplify server management --..." Read more... "The first alpha release of the 64-bit Adobe Flash Player 10 is amazingly stable and fast...." Read more... Read more Development posts or See all Blogs

Obama administration to inherit tough cybersecurity challenges Ballmer: Yahoo acquisition won't happen, despite Yang's departure Femtocell FAQ: Is it time for your own 'personal cell-phone tower'? More top stories...

Microsoft dumps OneCare, slates free security software for '09 Google deal produces 91% of Mozilla's revenue NASA successfully tests deep space Internet

2008 Salary Survey: IT pay takes tiny leaps If you're like our 7,000 survey respondents, your paycheck this year has been flattened and your bonus obliterated. We offer 12 ways to plump up your paycheck. Windows 7 in-depth review and video: This time Microsoft gets it right Microsoft's next OS might more accurately be called Windows 6.5: It's essentially a better version of Vista. Twitter for business: 5 ways to tap the power of the tweet Twitter can be a valuable business tool -- if you know what you're doing. Here's how to juice it for all it's worth. Microsoft's 'Vista Capable' changes outraged HP, insider e-mails show By helping Intel with loosened 'Vista Capable' requirements, Microsoft 'severely damaged' its credibility, said an HP exec in a newly unsealed Feb. 2006 e-mail. Windows 7 Get the latest news, reviews and more about Microsoft's newest desktop operating system More Continuing Coverage Windows 7 Voting Technology Google's Chrome browser Economy in turmoil: Latest news and tips iPhone 3G Bill Gates moves on Windows Vista A to Z Mac A to Z 2008 Salary Survey Find wage data for 50 IT job titles. More Special Reports 2008 Premier 100 IT Leaders 2007 Premier 100 IT Leaders 2008 Best Places to Work in IT 2007 Best Places to Work in IT 2008 Salary Survey 2007 Salary Survey 2006 Salary Survey 2008 IT Forecast 2007 IT Forecast 40 Years of Computerworld Top 12 Green-IT Users The FAQs About Going Green IT Schools to Watch iPhone: One Year Later Global Mobile Your Next Data Center Management: Reinventing IT Stop Data Leaks Web 2.0 Security Surviving Disasters Managing Storage Virtualization The Lean Storage Machine Storage on Trial Can Web 2.0 Save BI? Bypass These BI Potholes All Zones Business Continuity Zone The File Data Management Zone Security Management Zone The SAS Zone Business Intelligence and Analytics Zone The Enterprise Search Zone Software as a Service Zone The Security Zone See your link here

Quick Sizing Guide for SAS Grid Running on HP BladeSystems and EVA Storage Download this white paper today! (Source: HP) Designed for CIOs, IT managers, data center managers and grid computing architects seeking to improve performance, SAS Grid Computing on the HP BladeSystem c-Class helps accelerate growth and mitigate risks with a simplified, consolidated infrastructure that's agile enough to efficiently handle change. SAS Grid Manager on HP BladeSystem can lower costs through automation, virtualization and improved IT efficiency. Download this white paper  Google's Universal Search for Business Google's Universal Search for Business View this exclusive webcast, free, compliments of Google! Go to the webcast  Computerworld Technology Briefing: Meetings @ the Speed of Business Download this Technology Briefing now, compliments of Microsoft! (Source: Microsoft) For large organizations, Web conferencing gives a major boost to collaboration among far-flung offices. For smaller companies, experts say Web conferencing is no longer a luxury but a necessity for everything from webinars to customer presentations. But the real value lies in saving soft costs and in increases in productivity. Download this executive briefing  White Papers Read up on the latest ideas and technologies from companies that sell hardware, software and services. Deploying Virtualized NetWare on Linux Whitepaper Collaboration Tools and Organizational Success Driving Business Success Through Workgroup Choice and Flexibility View more whitepapers

• Obama administration to inherit tough cybersecurity challenges
• Microsoft dumps OneCare, slates free security software for '09
• Ballmer: Yahoo acquisition won't happen, despite Yang's departure
• More top stories 

The Enterprise Search Zone With an estimated 40% of the world's information now residing behind a firewall, employee productivity is driven by the ability to quickly find key information no matter where it's stored across your organization. At Google, we believe in a simple premise: all of the information you need to be productive at work should be available through one search box, giving users real-time access to content across the enterprise and delivering a single, integrated, secure set of search results. Learn more in The Enterprise Search Zone See All Zones

Creating Tiered Storage Architecture This paper shows how Brocade StorageX enables tiers of storage across Windows and NetApp storage to align storage practices with organizational objectives. Download this white paper now!