Sidebar: Reflections on Turbulent Times

Kathleen Melymuka   Today’s Top Stories   or  Other Management Stories  

Gain a faster, cheaper way to manage workload From Laggard to Leader: Transforming the Data Center Google's Universal Search for Business Deduplication and D2D Backup - Business and Technical Considerations Surviving and Thriving in Tough Times Success Story: Maine Medical Center The Business Value of Tape Storage Computerworld Technology Briefing: An open-source path to optimal virtualization Learn-Fast Guide: Get Up to Speed on Green IT Sign up to receive ROI Resource Alerts

May 17, 2004 (Computerworld) -- The publication this week of the book Does IT Matter? caps a year in which Nicholas G. Carr has become the poster boy for IT cost cutting and the villain IT partisans love to hate. He talked with Kathleen Melymuka about what it all means.

So much has happened since we first talked about your piece that appeared in Harvard Business Review last year . What has surprised you most about the response? The size of it. I certainly didn't expect that it would come to define the terms of debate in the IT field. I knew I was saying some controversial things, but I had no idea it would strike such a nerve. The second thing that surprises me is the incredible diversity of opinions that have been voiced about my ideas. It shows that companies and IT suppliers are coming at IT decisions from a wide range of perspectives. There's no one reigning philosophy about how to approach IT in business.
How do you respond to people who say that your argument is not only wrong but also dangerous in that it can cause companies to miss critical opportunities? I think managers are intelligent people, fully capable of thinking about diverse ideas and figuring out the best way to apply them to their own business. The real danger is in trying to silence the debate. Even the parts of the debate that have been critical of my article seem to me to be altogether healthy and, in the end, constructive.
Which parts of your argument do you find resonate most with IT folks? The idea that more and more of the hardware and software that companies buy has been commoditized and really doesn't provide much opportunity for competitive advantage or isn't particularly strategic. I think in the past few years, a lot of companies have embedded that view into the way they approach buying and managing IT resources. The debate seems to focus on whether there is some small slice that is not commoditized.
In your debates with IT leaders, have any of their counterarguments caused you to revise your own thinking? Some of the counterarguments have caused me to deepen my own thinking, and I try to express that in the book. For example, there were comments that commoditization applies to hardware but not to software. I don't think that's true. I think we are seeing the commoditization of business software in a broad manner. Another useful question was whether ongoing advances in IT architecture provide a basis for competitive advantage. It's true that we have seen a dramatic evolution in architecture, but I would argue that

Continued...
1 | 2 | NEXT  

Print this Story

Send Us Feedback

E-mail this Story

Digg this Story

Slashdot this Story

Follow, Don't Lead

Sidebar: Reflections on Turbulent Times

"The rumor is that Monty Widenius, founder of MySQL, has quit My question: Why shouldn't he?..." Read more... "An approaching hurricane fortuitously recalls the famous statement on planning from Eisenhower. We should heed his words...." Read more... Read more Management posts or See all Blogs

At 10, Google reiterates commitment to CIOs Microsoft explains Seinfeld-Windows TV ad: just a 'teaser' Continuing coverage: Google's Chrome browser More top stories...

iPhone 3G owner sues Apple, AT&T over dropped calls, app crashes Mozilla: Firefox is faster than Chrome Upcoming Microsoft patch lineup could be 'massive,' says researcher

Microsoft warns of IE8 lock-in with XP SP3 Users of Windows XP SP3 who try out IE8 Beta 2 won't be able to uninstall either one under certain circumstances. Opinion: Why Google has lost its mojo -- and why you should care Google has gone from innovative upstart to fat-and-happy industry leader in what seems like record time. Preston Gralla explains. Review: Internet Explorer 8 Beta 2 offers some nifty new features Microsoft's latest beta of IE8 includes better tab management, new services such as Web Slices and Accelerators, and the new 'porn mode.' IT Schools to Watch 2008 These leading-edge graduate schools are moving at the pace of the IT workplace, delivering coursework that's relevant to today's IT professionals. Windows Vista A to Z Reviews, analyses, how-tos, visual tours, hot issues and predictions about Microsoft's new OS. More Continuing Coverage After 9/11: Homeland Security Apple's iPhone Ask a Premier 100 IT Leader Bill Gates steps down BlackBerry Legal Battle Data Security Breaches Electronic Voting Firefox H-1B Visas HP's Boardroom Scandal Handheld Devices Hurricane Katrina Aftermath Microsoft Legal Issues Microsoft's Vista Open Source RFID Technology SCO's Linux Fight Sarbanes-Oxley Act Spam Voice Over IP Wi-Fi Windows Meta File Vulnerability Windows XP Service Pack 3 IT Careers 2010 Four years from now, the IT field will be a vastly different place. Will you be ready? More Special Reports Premier 100 IT Leaders 2007 Best in Class 2006 Computerworld Horizon Awards 2006 Premier 100 IT Leaders 2006 Salary Survey 2007 Best Places to Work in IT 2007 IT Forecast 2007 Premier 100 IT Leaders 40 Years of Computerworld ASPs, Take Two Best Places to Work in IT 2003 Best Places to Work in IT 2004 Best Places to Work in IT 2005 Best Places to Work in IT 2006 Business Intelligence Home Runs Business Intelligence: Smarter BI Business Intelligence: The Future of BI CRM Goes Vertical CRM: Sober CRM Career Planning Guide 2005 Careers: IT Profession 2010 Computerworld Horizon Awards 2005 Data Management: Mining for Gems Data Management: Taming Data Chaos Development: Hard-Workin' Web Sites Development: New Tools New Choices Development: The New World of Application Development Development: The Web Services Tsunami Development: Web Services Hurdles Disaster Recovery: Preparing for the Worst E-commerce Grows Up E-mail/Groupware: Big Decisions Faces of Mobile IT Forecast 2006 Global Mobile Hardware: Multiple Cores, Multiple Challenges Hardware: On-Demand Un-Hyped Hardware: The Shape of Things to Come Horizon Awards: 10 Cool Cutting Edge Technologies IT Management: Guide to Managing Vendors IT Management: Navigating Global IT IT Management: Recovery Ahead IT Management: The Future of IT IT Management: The Resourceful Project Manager Innovative Technology Awards 2004 Management: Reinventing IT Microsoft in Transition Mobile/Wireless Leaders and Laggards Mobile/Wireless: The Untethered Worker Mobile/Wireless: Tiny Gadgets, Huge Costs Network Management: Taking Control Networking: Turbulence Ahead! Networking: VoIP Goes Mainstream Operating Systems: In the Slow Lane Operating Systems: Linux Goes Global Operating Systems: Should You Nix Unix? Outsourcing: Offshore Buyer's Guide Outsourcing: Outsourcing Dangers Premier 100 IT Leaders 2004 Best in Class Premier 100 IT Leaders 2005 Best in Class ROI: Do the Math! Salary Survey 2003 Salary Survey 2004 Salary Survey 2005 Security Action Plan Security: Compliance Headaches Security: Proactive Security Security: Risk and Reward Security: Tips From Security Pros Souped-up Security Storage: Battling Complexity Storage: Cheap & Secure Data Stores Storage: Stretching Your Storage Dollars Storage: The Lean Storage Machine Storage: The New Rules of Storage Storage: The Ultimate Backup Guide Supply Chain: Missing Links Supply Chain: RFID Reality Check The Business of Security Web 2.0 Security Wireless: Wireless At Work All Zones Application Performance Zone Business Continuity Zone The File Data Management Zone Security Management Zone ITIL Best Practices Zone The SAS Zone Business Intelligence and Analytics Zone Windows Protection Zone Identity & Security Management Zone See your link here

Deploying Windows Vista to the Desktop: Get It Right with Dell Get this paper now! (Source: Dell) Dell has improved PC deployment activities through patent-pending automation technology and offers an array of services from planning a Windows Vista migration to post-deployment management. Download this white paper  Google's Universal Search for Business Google's Universal Search for Business View this exclusive webcast, free, compliments of Google! Go to the webcast  Learn-Fast Guide: Software as a Service is Growing Up Download this Computerworld Executive Briefing, a $195 value, for free! Compliments of Akamai. (Source: Computerworld) SaaS is here to stay as an application delivery channel. You will be using it, but will you do so wisely? This Learn-Fast Guide will prepare you for software delivered over the Web. From security issues to contract negotiations, there's a lot to consider ... and a lot to gain. Download this executive briefing  White Papers Read up on the latest ideas and technologies from companies that sell hardware, software and services. Death to PST: Hidden Cost of Email Mismanagement Extend, Replace, or Convert; which is the best way forward for COBOL Applications? The Trend from Unix to Linux in SAP Data Centers View more whitepapers

• Follow, Don't Lead
• Sidebar: Reflections on Turbulent Times

• At 10, Google reiterates commitment to CIOs
• iPhone 3G owner sues Apple, AT&T over dropped calls, app crashes
• Microsoft explains Seinfeld-Windows TV ad: just a 'teaser'
• More top stories 

SQL Anywhere Developer Edition Download SQL Anywhere is the industry-leading mobile and embedded database. Designed for database-powered applications that operate in frontline environments without onsite IT support, SQL Anywhere offers enterprise-caliber features in a database that is easily embedded and widely deployed in server, desktop, remote office and mobile applications. Download the free SQL Anywhere Developer Edition

Intercept Spam & Viruses With MessageLabs MessageLabs is offering a complimentary 30 day trial of its managed Anti-virus and Anti-spam security solutions. MessageLabs guarantees complete protection against all know and unknown email threats. By providing 24 hour support, your business can increase productivity and decrease risk. Register for a complimentary trial and receive a free datasheet. Download this white paper now!