Subscribe to our e-mail newsletters
For more info on a specific newsletter, click the title. Details will be displayed in a new window.
CareerMail
Computerworld Daily News (First Look and Wrap-Up)
Computerworld Blogs Newsletter
The Weekly Top 10
More E-Mail Newsletters 
Computerworld 2007Subscribe to Computerworld
40 years of the most authoritative source of news and information for IT leaders.

IT Pros Blast ITAA Skills Shortage Report

IT employees are disputing a recent report of a skills shortage.
 

Sign up to receive Security Resource Alerts

June 03, 2002 (Computerworld) -- With 35 years of IT experience and expertise in C++, Java and other technical skills in high demand, Warren MacQueen thinks he should have no problem landing a job.


But the Kansas City-area IT veteran said that after falling victim to mass layoffs at Sprint Corp. in November, he sent out 100 resumes and heard back from only a handful of companies. "I don't think that my skill set is inadequate," he said.


MacQueen is one of scores of IT workers who were angered by last month's Information Technology Association of America report, which claimed there's a shortage of U.S. workers with the right IT skills (see story).


The study projected that despite a 5% dip in the IT job market last year, upward of 1.1 million jobs will be created this year. However, it continued, less than half of those will be filled because workers don't have the right skills. Critics claim that there aren't any jobs in sight and that the supposed IT skills shortage is a myth perpetuated by big business and lobbyists trying to preserve the current employers' market.


"[The study] doesn't seem to jibe with the facts, so you question if there's a hidden agenda or just a lack of judgment," said Ray Hooker, a networking consulting engineer at Cisco Systems Inc.


However, ITAA spokesman Bob Cohen said the report is a forecast rather than an indicator of current conditions. A telephone-based survey of 532 managers across a variety of industries found that companies are struggling to find workers with technical expertise, domain knowledge and project experience, he said.


"People's frustration is understandable, because times have changed and it's more difficult to drive your career than it was in 1999 and 2000," said Cohen. "But you can't overlook what the requirements are or what the hiring companies' views are."


One factor fueling the uproar over the study is that the Arlington, Va.-based ITAA is one of the nation's biggest supporters of the H-1B temporary foreign visa program.


Some critics charged that the skills shortage study was just an attempt to persuade Congress to raise the H-1B cap and flood the IT job market with lower-paid foreigners in order to drive down salaries.


Hooker said he's not opposed to the H-1B program and added that many foreign workers are better educated and more up to date on IT skills than their U.S. counterparts. But, he said, American workers with significant job experience who are equally or more qualified are being shut out by an oversaturated job market.


"We wouldn't want to allow undercutting of existing [U.S.] workers," said Hooker. "I respect [foreign workers'] skills, but a 25-year-old with two years' experience is still a 25-year-old with two years' experience."


Tom Scott, president of the San Diego Oracle Users Group, is one of many skeptics of the skills shortage who said he often sees phony job listings likely geared toward hiding the job shortage. Scott and others say they can tell the ads are phony because the job listings typically ask for an impossible combination of skills and certifications. "They want every acronym under the sun for $30 [an hour]," Scott said.


Another issue is an age-old problem: human resources professionals who lack IT skills but are responsible for filling highly technical posts.


But that argument is always used when the market is down, countered the ITAA's Cohen.


"In good times, [recruiters are] brilliant, and in bad times, they don't know what they're doing," he said.


Different Perspectives


Indeed, the ITAA's contention that companies are having trouble filling jobs does have some backing. Hiring managers are split on the job-shortage/skills-shortage debate, with some supporting the findings that were detailed in the ITAA's report.


At Delaware Investments in Philadelphia, IT jobs are scarce—as are jobs across the company—because they're being filled only if they're deemed critical, said company spokesman Tom Gariepy.


IT job openings at Lockheed Martin Corp. are also down, though not as drastically as at other companies, said Don Peterman, director of employment for the company's Delaware Valley Regional Recruiting Center.


Last year, Bethesda, Md.-based Lockheed filled about 700 IT jobs, and it expects to fill about half that number this year, said Peterman. Since the middle of last year, every job opening at the company has generated a flood of resumes, with more than enough qualified candidates, he added.


Still, finding qualified IT candidates to fill open positions is a big challenge, said Nicole Tucker, a recruiter at Philadelphia-based Peco Energy Co., a subsidiary of Chicago-based Exelon Corp.


"It's really tough for us to find very specialized people," she said, adding that applicants for the eight to 10 high-level IT jobs that open each year lack either degrees or business knowledge and project management expertise. The company often decides to hire its contractors for full-time jobs because they have developed the right skill sets while at Peco, Tucker added.


Kathy Walters, vice president of IT at Exelon's energy division in Philadelphia, said her unit is fully staffed now. But when positions do open up in the division, Walters said, she gets many resumes but few from qualified candidates.


"Finding the right match for what you have to spend is tough," Walters said.





















Factors Driving IT Job Shortage


Corporate consolidation resulting in job cuts


Former dot-com employees flooding the corporate IT market


Slashed IT budgets that fund only mission-critical projects


Employers cutting experienced, high-paid workers, and replacing them with younger, lower-paid workers


IT departments pushing employees to work longer and harder


Companies hiring temporary contractors and pushing work overseas





Print this Story Send Us Feedback E-mail this Story Digg! Digg this Story Slashdot this Story
Converging Forces Drive Job Shortage
Workers blast ITAA study claims
"Are you the uber-geek at your job who holds all the pieces of the network and security together? If so,..." Read more...
"Today, CIO means being more than a competent manager of IT. It should mean Lord of Process, and we should..." Read more...
Read more Careers posts or See all Blogs
Microsoft to limit capabilities of cheap laptops
FBI worried as DoD sold counterfeit networking gear
Update: Microsoft to appeal $1.3B EU fine
More top stories...
XP SP3 cripples some PCs with endless reboots
Windows Vista more secure than XP, says security company
Microsoft grows DAISY for blind computer users while Adobe wilts
Mistakes such as putting down co-workers or burning bridges when you resign are surefire ways to darken your career prospects. Here's how to avoid them
Hype and promises abound in the IT world, but these six breakthroughs really will change your life, says author and former IT manager John Brandon.
Baby boomers are retiring and taking their knowledge with them. Why do so few in IT seem to care?
Computerworld editors share stories of their first PCs, including some classics and some real clunkers -- then we ask readers to share their early-PC tales.
Reviews, analyses, how-tos, visual tours, hot issues and predictions about Microsoft's new OS.
Four years from now, the IT field will be a vastly different place. Will you be ready?
All Zones
Application Performance Zone
Enterprise-Class Security Zone
Enterprise Solutions Zone
The File Data Management Zone
Grid Computing on Windows Zone
Security Management Zone
ITIL Best Practices Zone
The SAS Zone
Storage Virtualization Zone
The Data Center Management Zone

Ads by TechWords

See your link here
Computerworld Report: Virtual Reality
Download this Computerworld Report, free for a limited time, compliments of HP.
(Source: Computerworld) The data center is real, but storage is turning virtual at many organizations that need to manage exploding storage needs. Learn how virtualizing your enterprise will save you money in this Computerworld Report, a $49.95 value, available free for a limited time, compliments of HP.
Download this executive briefing download
Long Tail Supplier Collaboration - What's In It For You?
Long Tail Supplier Collaboration - What's In It For You?
Download this webcast, free, compliments of Sterling Commerce
Go to the webcast 
Transformational Analytics: Virtualizing IT Environments
Download this white paper, free, compliments of CiRBA.
(Source: CiRBA) The overwhelming complexity of the modern data center compounds the problem of how to safely virtualize IT environments. This paper provides an in-depth guide to analyzing complex environments for virtualization opportunities, particularly within production environments where stability, service levels and performance are of the upmost performance.
Download this white paper go
White Papers
Read up on the latest ideas and technologies from companies that sell hardware, software and services.
New Fujitsu High-End Itanium Windows- and Linux-Based PRIMEQUEST Servers Offer the Utmost in High Availability
New Fujitsu High-End Itanium-Based PRIMEQUEST Servers Offer Industry-Leading System Management for Linux and Windows
Symantec State of the Data Center Report 2007
View more whitepapers