Chinese hackers dig into new IE bug, says Google researcher

Microsoft asked Google security engineer to delay release of fuzzer, other information because of 'PR concerns'

An accidental leak may have confirmed Chinese hackers' suspicions that Internet Explorer has a critical unpatched vulnerability, a security researcher said Saturday.

Sunday, Microsoft said it was analyzing the vulnerability.

The bug was one of about 100 found by noted browser vulnerability researcher and Google security engineer Michal Zalewski using a new "fuzzing" tool. The vulnerabilities were in IE, Firefox, Chrome, Safari and Opera.

"I have reasons to believe that the evidently exploitable vulnerability [in IE] discoverable by cross_fuzz is independently known to third parties in China," said Zalewski, referring to the "cross_fuzz" fuzzing utility he created.

According to Zalewski's account, a developer working on WebKit -- the open-source browser engine that powers both Apple's Safari and Google's Chrome -- "accidentally leaked" the location of the then-unreleased fuzzing tool. Google's search engine then added that location to its index.

"On Dec. 30, I received ... search queries from an IP address in China, which matched keywords mentioned in one of the indexed cross_fuzz files," Zalewski said.

Those searches were looking for information on a pair of functions in "Mshtml.dll," IE's browser engine, that Zalewski said were unique to the vulnerability, and that had "absolutely no other mentions on the Internet at that time."

The person or persons searching for the functions then downloaded all the available cross_fuzz files.

"[This] is very strongly indicative of an independent discovery of the same fault condition in [IE] unrelated means; other explanations for this pair of consecutive searches seem extremely unlikely," Zalewski said.

Zalewski released cross_fuzz on Saturday, even though Microsoft had not yet patched any of the IE flaws. Other browser makers, including Mozilla and Opera, as well as the WebKit team, have fixed some -- although not all -- of the bugs Zalewski found using cross_fuzz.

Microsoft asked Zalewski to delay cross_fuzz's release, but he declined, in part because of his fear the IE vulnerability was already being explored by Chinese hackers, but also because the company's security experts had not responded to information he provided.

"Since [Microsoft has] not provided an explanation as to why these issues could not be investigated earlier, I refused [the request to hold the release]," Zalewski said in a Jan. 1 post to the Full Disclosure mailing list.

In a detailed timeline of his communiqués to Microsoft, Zalewski said he had first reported his findings and provided an earlier version of cross_fuzz in July. According to Zalewski, Microsoft did not reply until he told them on Dec. 20 that he was planning on revealing the fuzzing tool in early January.

On Dec. 21, Microsoft told Zalewski that its security response center had begun composing a reply last summer, but never sent it after failing to reproduce his findings.

"I have a conference call with MSRC [Microsoft Security Response Center]," Zalewski said in the timeline's note for Dec. 28. "The team expresses concern over PR impact, suggests that the changes made to my fuzzer code between July and December might have uncovered additional issues, which would explain why they were unable to reproduce them earlier."

A day later, Microsoft admitted it was now able to reproduce the fuzzer-found flaws using the July code.

"The IE team did exhaustively run the fuzzers but were unable to find the same crashes that you and Dave [of Microsoft] are now able to identify," Microsoft told Zalewski on Dec. 29. "I can't really say as to why we are able to hit some of these conditions now rather than before but please know that this was not intentional."

Microsoft's account omitted most of the details Zalewski provided, including the fact that it was able last month to reproduce the vulnerability using the fuzzer it had five months earlier.

"[In July], neither Microsoft or the Google security researcher identified any issues," said Jerry Bryant, an MSRC spokesman, in a statement Sunday. "On December 21, a new version of the tool was reported to us along with information about a potentially exploitable crash found by the new version. We immediately worked to reproduce the issue with the updated and original tool and are currently investigating it further to determine if it is actually exploitable."

Microsoft and Google security researchers have crossed swords in the past. Last summer, Google's Tavis Ormandy released exploit code for a bug in Windows' Help and Support Center after he said Microsoft refused to set a patch deadline.

Fuzzing is a common research practice used to locate vulnerabilities and find flaws in code. A fuzzer automates the technique by inputting data into applications or operating system components to see if -- and where -- crashes occur.

The vulnerability that Zalewski reported and Microsoft said it was investigating is apparently unrelated to the unpatched IE bug the latter confirmed on Dec. 22.

Gregg Keizer covers Microsoft, security issues, Apple, Web browsers and general technology breaking news for Computerworld. Follow Gregg on Twitter at @gkeizer or subscribe to Gregg's RSS feed . His e-mail address is gkeizer@computerworld.com.

From CIO: 8 Free Online Courses to Grow Your Tech Skills
Join the discussion
Be the first to comment on this article. Our Commenting Policies