Ecuador considers Snowden's asylum request

Ecuador's minister of foreign affairs comments on asylum request at a press conference

Ecuador is considering U.S. National Security Agency leaker Edward Snowden's asylum request and has been maintaining diplomatic contact with Russia, said Ricardo Patino Aroca, Ecuador's minister of Foreign Affairs, Trade and Integration, on Monday.

Ecuador's Foreign Minister Ricardo Patino
Ecuador's Foreign Minister Ricardo Patino speaks with the news media at his hotel in Hanoi on Monday. Patino, currently on a visit to Vietnam, said his nation has received a request for political asylum from Edward Snowden, the former U.S. National Security Agency contractor, but no decision has been made. (Photo: Kham/Reuters)

"Ecuador is considering Mr. Snowden's asylum request," said Patino at a press conference in Hanoi during a visit to Vietnam's foreign minister. The event was live-streamed on the Internet in Spanish and an instant English translation was provided by the BBC.

"All of us know he has arrived in the Russian Federation," Patino said. The Russian government must decide how to handle Snowden in accordance with the country's laws, Patino said. However, when asked directly, Patino said he did not know where the leaker was. "Specific information as to his whereabouts ... we cannot share that at this moment. We don't have it and we can't share it," Patino said.

Snowden requested asylum in Ecuador because the U.S. has announced a criminal investigation against him, he wrote in his asylum request, Patino said. Because Snowden has been accused of being a traitor, life in prison is among the possible sentences, Snowden wrote, according to Patino.

In his request, Snowden mentioned that Ecuador granted asylum to WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange, who remains in the Ecuadorian embassy in London, Patino said. Snowden compared his situation to Bradley Manning's, who leaked U.S. diplomatic cables to WikiLeaks and who, Snowden said, was treated inhumanely during his time in a U.S. prison, according to Patino.

Snowden also said he believes he will not receive a fair trial in the U.S. and thus requested asylum, according to Patino.

Earlier Monday, Snowden was reportedly en route to Ecuador from Moscow via Havana. However, he wasn't on the plane as expected, according to an Associated Press reporter.

Patino declined to discuss how Snowden would reach Ecuador if his asylum request is granted.

Patino also questioned whether what Snowden did was treason. "We have to ask who has betrayed whom," he said. A global espionage plot like Prism -- the U.S. government's surveillance program, whose details were leaked by Snowden -- does not only affect U.S. citizens but would violate the rights of every citizen in the world, Patino said. Revealing such a monitoring program might not be treason against the world's citizens but is more likely to be treason against a group of powerful leaders, he suggested.

The current NSA leaks would have been helpful at the time of the Iraqi invasion that was "based on completely false information," Patino said. "Wouldn't it have been convenient to have known that before?" he asked, adding that knowing the truth upfront could have prevented the deaths of hundreds of thousands, and could have avoided the sorrow of a nation.

Reporters' questions at the press conference suggested that sheltering people like Assange and Snowden could be harmful for the Ecuadorian-U.S. relationship. "Of course we are aware of the consequences of our decisions," Patino said, when asked what effect the possible asylum for Snowden would have on Ecuador's relationship with the U.S. However, the U.S. and Ecuador are both sovereign countries that make sovereign decisions, he said.

Moreover, Ecuador has requested the extradition of Ecuadorian citizens who fled to the U.S. on several occasions, Patino said. In those cases the U.S. exercised its sovereignty and decided not to extradite those people, owners of banks, who have harmed millions of Ecuadorians, he said.

Ecuador places human rights above any other principle, Patino said, adding that is one of the main reasons Snowden's asylum request is being considered. Patino also quoted several articles from the Ecuadorian constitution, one of which states that spying on citizens is illegal.

He also referred to the protection of human rights in the U.N.'s Universal Declaration of Human Rights, adding that the Fourth and Fifth amendments in the U.S. Constitution also address related issues.

To express your thoughts on Computerworld content, visit Computerworld's Facebook page, LinkedIn page and Twitter stream.
Windows 10 annoyances and solutions
Shop Tech Products at Amazon
Notice to our Readers
We're now using social media to take your comments and feedback. Learn more about this here.