HTC's first net loss in a decade could signal its collapse in two years

HTC now on same track of decline as Nokia, BlackBerry

HTC's net loss of $101 million for the third quarter as reported Thursday might not sound all that traumatic, but in today's fiercely competitive smartphone market it could signal the beginning of the end for the phone maker.

HTC One smartphone
The HTC One smartphone received great reviews but also faced intense competition with Android devices from Samsung, Huawei, Lenovo, LG, Sony and ZTE.

Despite producing a fleet of superior smartphones such as the HTC One launched in April, the Taiwanese handset maker has suffered from marketing and brand recognition woes. Even the stylish and powerful HTC One hasn't sold as well as expected, partly because its rollout was delayed earlier in the year due to technical problems.

The $101 million loss for the quarter ending Sept. 30 marked the first such loss since HTC went public in 2002. That low-water mark could spell disaster.

"Once a company begins to generate negative operating margins from phone sales, that phone business never recovers," said Horace Dediu, an analyst at Asymco in a blog on Friday.

Dediu's perspective is not just his opinion, but is based on tracking the decline of other smartphone makers, including Nokia and BlackBerry. Both companies are in the process of being sold: Nokia to Microsoft and BlackBerry to Fairfax Financial Holdings.

After a smartphone maker hits a rough spot with a negative quarter, Dediu said it becomes a question of how long it will suffer in a "post-traumatic" period before being sold, dissolved or merged. Both Nokia and BlackBerry had about two years in "post-trauma" before their sales to other companies were initiated, while the trauma clock has recently started for HTC.

"The implication [is] that HTC will change ownership or control no later than mid-2015," Dediu said. LG Electronics could be considered an exception to the pattern, having suffered a loss four years ago and yet it still remains in the phone business and seems to be recovering.

But LG benefits by offsetting phone losses with cash from other businesses it holds, while BlackBerry and Nokia (and others) have derived most of their sales from phones.

The decline of a smartphone company after a financial quarter with a loss is unusual, when compared with traditional industries, because the smartphone industry is so dynamic and cutthroat. Samsung dominates in sales, followed closely by Apple. For sure, in some traditional industries like automobiles, a company can regain success, even after a bankruptcy.

Not so in smartphones.

"The end is closing in on [wireless handset] vendors that don't have other high-revenue generating businesses that can help them persevere over the long term in handsets," said Kevin Burden, an analyst at Strategy Analytics. As with other technology segments, "having the best technology or the best product has rarely been a guarantee for success," he said.

To add insult to injury, as HTC was reporting its third-quarter loss, Samsung said Thursday it expected record profits of $9.3 billion for the third quarter partly because of an increase in sales of its chips amid a contraction in smartphone sales.

Samsung is widely regarded as superior in marketing when compared to other smartphone makers, except perhaps Apple.

HTC's problems really started in 2012, when it shipped 31 million smartphones, according to IDC. That number was down 27% from 2011, making 2012 the first year-over-year decline for HTC.

1 2 Page
FREE Computerworld Insider Guide: IT Certification Study Tips
Join the discussion
Be the first to comment on this article. Our Commenting Policies