Optimus G Pro vs. Galaxy Note II: It's really no contest

Optimus G Pro vs. Galaxy Note II

Some smartphone comparisons require a lot of thought and analysis. Others are absurdly simple.

Today's comparison is one of the easy ones: the case of the new LG Optimus G Pro and its primary rival, the Samsung Galaxy Note II. The Optimus G Pro launches in the U.S. today, giving Samsung its first real competitor in the supersized smartphone market.

I spent a week using the Optimus G Pro in place of my own personal device. You can read through my full review for a detailed look at what the phone's like to use in the real world; if you're at all interested in a plus-sized smartphone, I'd strongly suggest you do.

As for the Optimus G Pro vs. Note II comparison, here's the short answer: The Optimus G Pro is basically a better version of the Note II, just without the stylus. Unless you really need a native stylus or are unconditionally in love with the Samsung brand, the Optimus G Pro is hands-down the superior device.

Optimus G Pro Galaxy Note II Chart

Check out the chart at right for a side-by-side view of the phones' key specs. Oddly enough, it's the fact that the Optimus G Pro is so similar to the Note II that makes the comparison such a no-brainer: The two phones share the same basic size, shape, and approach to hardware design.

The Optimus G Pro, however, is a fifth of an inch narrower than the Note II -- a seemingly small amount that makes a big difference when it comes to the comfort of holding a device this large. It's slightly lighter, too, by about a fifth of an ounce.

The Optimus G Pro has a dramatically better screen, with a 1080p LCD display compared to the Note II's 720p AMOLED. In addition to packing significantly more pixels -- 400 pixels per inch vs. the Note II's 267 -- the LCD technology boasts a major advantage over AMOLED when it comes to visibility in glary outdoor conditions.

Beyond that, the Optimus G Pro has a more advanced processor and double the amount of onboard storage (within the U.S. models).

And then there's the software: The Optimus G Pro shows what a Samsung product could be if it had less focus on gimmicky, marketing-friendly glitz and more focus on a cohesive overall user experience. The Optimus G Pro has fewer flashy features than a Samsung device, but the ones that are there actually matter (and, for the most part, are actually reliable). The phone's user interface is relatively simple, subdued, and visually consistent, too -- qualities Samsung devices certainly can't claim.

The one caveat -- and it's an annoying one -- is that the device is currently an AT&T exclusive. LG really stabbed itself in the foot with that decision; single-carrier availability is no way to sell a phone these days.

Android Power Twitter

But if AT&T's an option for you, unless you need a native stylus or have Apple-like devotion to Samsung, it's hard to find much reason to recommend a Note II over an Optimus G Pro.

Like I said -- this one's easy.

Optimus G Pro deep-dive review: A supersized smartphone done right

To express your thoughts on Computerworld content, visit Computerworld's Facebook page, LinkedIn page and Twitter stream.
Windows 10 annoyances and solutions
Shop Tech Products at Amazon
Notice to our Readers
We're now using social media to take your comments and feedback. Learn more about this here.