Here's why Windows 8 will never approach Vista's awfulness

Windows 8 has taken plenty of criticism since its release. But even though it's been called as big a bomb as Vista, Windows 8 will have much more success than that version of Windows. Here's why.

Let's start out with the most basic reason Windows 8 isn't as bad as Vista: Windows 8 will likely gain a greater market share than Vista ever did. According to Net Applications figures, Vista's greatest market share for a year was only 17.73%, in 2009. Windows 7 very quickly eclipsed Vista after it was released.

Windows 8 may be off to a sluggish start, but there's a reasonable chance it will end up surpassing Vista's high point, at least if you take tablets into account. Net Applications latest figures show Windows 8 with a 3.82% market share in April, up from 3.17% in March. In January it was at 2.26%. Certainly not great, but a rise of more than 1.5% in three months, and more important, a rise of more than .5% in a single month. If you take tablets into account, Windows 8's market share in April was 3.84%.

There's a good chance that Net Applications is underestimating Windows tablet market share. The latest figures from Strategy Analytics shows that Windows tablets had 7.5% of the tablet market for the first quarter of 2013, with 3 million shipped. Not stellar numbers, certainly, but it shows that Windows 8 is gaining a toehold in the tablet market.

Taking tablets into account, and given Windows 8 slowly accelerating sales, it's not unreasonable to expect that Windows 8 could gain 10% to 12% or more of market share per year. That would mean that by sometime next year, it could exceed Windows Vista's top market share.

The other main reason Windows 8 won't eventually be considered as bad as Vista was is that even though it's a kludge of an operating system, it was at least an attempt to make something truly new -- the melding of mobile and desktop. It also will likely help usher in an era in which touch will become more a part of people's daily computing lives. And under the hood, it offers considerable performance increases.

All this doesn't mean that I've suddenly become a fan of Windows 8. I still think it was a mistake to build a single operating system for tablets and traditional computers. And saying that it's better than Vista isn't much more than damning it with faint praise. Ultimately I expect that the next major version of Windows may well fix many of Windows 8's problems, the same way that Windows 7 did for Vista.

To express your thoughts on Computerworld content, visit Computerworld's Facebook page, LinkedIn page and Twitter stream.
Windows 10 annoyances and solutions
Shop Tech Products at Amazon
Notice to our Readers
We're now using social media to take your comments and feedback. Learn more about this here.