Trade in an iPad for a Surface tablet? Epic fail!

Here's Microsoft's brainstorm for boosting Surface tablet sales: Get people to trade in their iPads for them. Is this a Saturday Night Live skit or a real offer?

The offer on Microsoft's Web site says that consumers can bring in a "gently used iPad 2, 3, or 4" and in return get a minimum of $200 to be used towards a Surface tablet, or another product from the Microsoft store. Although the money can be used for any product, Microsoft has geared the deal heavily towards the Surface, highlighting the RT-based Surface and Surface Pro multiple times at the top of the offer page.

You won't know exactly how much you get until you bring your "gently used" iPad to a Microsoft store, though. As Computerworld's Gregg Keizer points out, "Because the buyback program isn't available online, it's impossible to tell what Microsoft will pay for an iPad before going to a store."

Microsoft has been trying to hit Apple hard to get people to buy Surface tablets rather than iPads. There's currently a ubiquitous TV ad campaign showing off what Microsoft believes are the superiority of its tablets over iPads, such as a keyboard, although the ad doesn't mention that the keyboard typically adds to the price of a Surface.

Microsoft certainly needs to do something to get some market share from Apple. IDC figures show the iPad with 32.5% share of the tablet market, with Windows tablets (including Windows RT) at 4.5%. The Surface RT disaster may have been a contributing factor to Ballmer leaving Microsoft, with the company writing down $900 million because of unsold RT inventory.

And the specs for both the RT-based and Windows 8.1-based Surface 2 doen't look particularly compelling, either. They're essentially the same as the existing hardware with a better processor and a few small bells and whistles, such as a better "kickstand." The new RT-based tablet is expected to sell for $499. That won't bring in many buyers.

As to how many people will likely trade in their iPads and put the money towards a Surface, that's anyone's guess. My guess is that it won't be many -- probably about as many as you can count on the right hand of Hall of Fame pitcher Mordecai "Three-Finger" Brown.

To express your thoughts on Computerworld content, visit Computerworld's Facebook page, LinkedIn page and Twitter stream.
Windows 10 annoyances and solutions
Shop Tech Products at Amazon
Notice to our Readers
We're now using social media to take your comments and feedback. Learn more about this here.